James McAvoy toppled Ewan McGregor in last week's all-Scottish contest, scoring 132 votes to his rival's 61. The comment of the week came from Robin in Utah, who described James as "geeky, cheeky, smoldering, innocent, naughty, funny, heartbreaking. . . but all the while unquestionably sexy!" That just about sums it up, don't you think?

Anyway, if you like your men rugged and outdoorsy, you'll enjoy this week's Face Off, a battle between two toned, tanned hunks who know definitely how to start a campfire.


Mr. Holloway...
Mr. McConaughey...
  • Plays James "Sawyer" Ford in Lost
  • Has starred in TV ads for Davidoff Cool Water and Magnum ice cream (yum!)

  • Recently appeared shirtless on Gay Spy
  • Appears in various rom-coms

  • Has starred in TV ads for Stetson Black cologne and Dolce and Gabbana
  • Recently appeared shirtless on Gay Spy
Which guy would you spend a night under the stars with? Use the space below to cast your vote, giving as many reasons for your choice as you like.