Agree with our review? Let us know your thoughts on this single below, and don't forget to include your rating out of five!
Average:

Your responses
S Cheshire on January 9th, 2007
There are always going to be people who prefer the original, but on this .. maybe its just a nostalgia thing going on .. This is good enough to be the original .. different .. but if you didnt know the original exisited .. you know its gonna be a classic ..
Caroline, Denmark on July 15th, 2006
I'm not a fan of artists taking over "old" songs. But Mary J Blige is really giving this "One" new life. I agree with Lynn Tyeson, nothing less than brilliant performance from Mary.
Matt Smith, Australia`` on July 3rd, 2006
Unreal! I absolutely ADORE this version of the song, Blige brings a fresh feel to one of my favourite songs, now THIS version is my favourite!!!! Blige is the BUSINESS!!!
Majken, Denmark on June 26th, 2006
Ubeskrivelig fænomonal sang!! GREAT SONG!
Amara on June 20th, 2006
Its great!!
Ana, Portugal on June 3rd, 2006
I love that song! It's my favorite!!
K, Manchester on May 27th, 2006
An amazin song and video, LOVE IT, think its 1 of the best duets ever!!!!
Vit, Argentina on May 20th, 2006
I have heard that One was recently chosen as the best song in history. Mmmm, I am not sure about that, but what I can say for sure is that Mary J´s performance was breathtaking and that it made me like this powerful version 10 times better than the original one
Kristoffer, Denmark on May 9th, 2006
I really like this version... And I disagree with Anon fro Essex! Everybody knows that U2 made this song - Bono just got an award for best songwriting because of One! I actually dont like U2. Im sure that they are good musicians, but their music have never done it for me... But with this version of One, I really listen to the song and read the lyrics... And love it! So if the mission is to get the point of "One" out to people who dont listen to U2... its completed! People who finds the original version better, can just ignore this one:)
robyn jones ,royston herts on April 23rd, 2006
i love this song. im only 14 but i just really love it and i think their voices match really well. I listen to it 24/7. Its' a really good song altogether.
Rachel, Preston on April 21st, 2006
I think that this song is fabbbb!
Lynn Tyeson, Glasgow on April 17th, 2006
Huge U2 Fan, thought Mary J's performance BRILLIANT. Has made me look at an artist I did not appreciate before - awaiting delivery of Mary's album.....
Willy Jon, Cheshire on April 17th, 2006
mjb is the gaffer she has talent and class and is a unique sound...all the other pretenders like beyonce et al can only dream of being like mjb. she has a gift and thankfully she is preared to share it with us by giving her performances everything she has from her considerable emotional resources. I'm not a fan of r and b but I know a top class performer when I see one
Patrick McGuinness, Wirral on April 16th, 2006
Mary J Blige has one of the most amazing voices around and U2 are still going strong. U2 are rock legends that will be remembered forever. I'm surprised that the original only got to no.7 and this one has only got to no.2. I think One is a hell of a lot better than Crazy from Gnarls Barkley.
Colleen, Germany on April 9th, 2006
I am a huge U2 fan, I've seen them live and nothing was more moving than hearing them sing "One". This cover with MJB is not even trying to be better it's just trying to refresh a fabulous song and spread it through a wider audience. The fact that Bono and the band are so happy with it should be enough for even the most die hard U2 fans to accept it and love it. Also listen to MJB's final vocals ......totally amazing and just goes to show what fabulous range she really has. A good one off partnership I would say and that's why I rate it 5. :-)
SARAH SMITH, GREAT BRITAIN on April 7th, 2006
I THINK THAT THIS TRACK IS SOOOO WICKED. EVERYTIME I HEAR IT, I FALL IN LOVE WITH IT. I FEEL SO CONNECTED TO IT. I ALWAYS GO HOME AND WAIT FOR THIS TRACK TO COME ON.
Stew, Ireland on April 5th, 2006
Neither are as good as Johnny Cash's version
Jess, Lancashire on April 2nd, 2006
I can really say this is a good song. I like how they have brought together two strong voices and made "one" a good hit. Both original and this one as good as the other, both will be remembered for their different qualities.
jade, london, uk on March 30th, 2006
I absolutely love this song and the music vid, can't wait till it's released on single, I will def buy it. Both singers vocals really shine in the track.
Anon, Essex on March 27th, 2006
I agree with Dave 'One' is my favourite record and the original is fantastic and should be appreciated as it is. Now Mary J Blige has released it those people who don't really know U2's music will only know this americanised version of it.