Average:

Your responses
James, Shropshire on November 11th, 2008
Cathy from Aylesbury, I agree :) They should pay more attention to the Arthur/Merlin relationship. The episode was one of the best, I think...still a bit annoyed wiht the writers, though.
sam, lancs on November 10th, 2008
the talented cast save the day with a plot as thin as ice - very good viewing!
wendy on November 9th, 2008
I really love merlin it is good family entertainment the acting from all is great. Elizabeth(nov 2cnd) what are you watching it for you obviously don't like the series . Did you know there are buttons on tv's where you can either turn off or change channels?

Mark Anthony Craig, Wirral, UK on November 6th, 2008
Let's face it, with Doctor Who off-air, British television needs another Saturday evening piece of escapist fantasy the whole family can enjoy. Merlin fits this bill very well indeed and is developing nicely; I - for one - certainly hope that series 1 won't be the last. As watchable as X-Factor may be to some (and becoming increasingly tediously boring to others), there are just too many "wanna-be-stars" programmes, "reality shows" and foul-mouthed wanna-be so-called comedians sloshing around our television screens like an unwelcome tsunami. When tv executives do allow something "different" to be screened, some people want to criticise every aspect of it they can think of. But be honest, without Merlin, Saturday evening telly wouldn't be worth switching the tv on for. The Beeb took a risk making this, and we should congratulate everyone involved.
Steve G. N.Yorks on November 5th, 2008
This series is getting better. And I'm sure it will develop as it approaches the end of THIS series! I also think it has done very well in the ratings, considering the BBC have put it up against ITV's No.1 show!!!
Cathy, Aylesbury on November 5th, 2008
I love this show, it's not accurate, but who gives a trifle? The acting is good, especially when concerning Colin Morgan, the script is fairly good, there's oodles of humour, and it's watchable for all ages. What's not to like? I love the interaction between Merlin and Arthur, and feel that they should focus more on that. But that's probably because I'm a fourteen-year-old fangirl... Oh well... Arthur + Merlin = LOVE. LOOOVVEEE.
Emer, Ireland on November 4th, 2008
I'm sorry Elizabeth have to disagree Morgan's Merlin is fantastic just a pity he wasn't given a proper chance! I say give him a job on Robin Hood!
ThomsonsPier, Reading on November 4th, 2008
Much as I like the show, Merlin continues to demonstrate mediocre writing and a lack of atmosphere. A slow build up is generally accompanied by character development, but we still have little more than cardboard cut-out heroes and villains. Besides this, I was under the impression that the show was called 'Merlin', not 'Pendragon Weekly'. The titular character is still the weakest (though one of the strongest and most likeable actors) and with the least developed background.

Rosie, Scotland on November 3rd, 2008
Really enjoyed this episode. Wonderfully played by Colin Morgan. This is really good saturday night entertainment and should really not be expected to be anything else - especially on a TV budget. I do think the writers could have done a bit better all round - they have some very strong actors to work with and should use them to the full. However our family adore this show and we would not miss it. We are certainly looking forward to how the key characters develop - there are signs that things are starting to become interesting (e.g. Morgana suspects that Merlin had something to do with Artur's rescue etc etc.)
Phil, Sheffield on November 3rd, 2008
Best yet. Not too keen on Ms Grainger's performance (and, without being harsh, I found it difficult to believe Arthur would fall for her so easily before the enchantment, especially with Morgana looking more beautiful every time she appears on screen)
Michael, Shrewsbury on November 2nd, 2008
Get Merlin outta the stocks!! What's Uther playing at? Merlin's saved his son's life a few times, and Uther still treats him like crap. Of course, each TV programme needs a character who we can all hate, but it is a bit boring...and Arthur should be a bit more manly and stand up for MErlin once in a while...I think the writers weren't really bothered about this programme.
Emer Ireland on November 2nd, 2008
Why is the BBC not providing good decent writing to obviously an increditably talented cast? The first few were impressive but it seems to have gone downhill since.
Alex - Essex on November 2nd, 2008
Another great episode again... The best part was when I saw some cool fairy like creatures and also the special effects through out the episode. Also what is interesting that after every episode you can go online and watch a magic trick that merlin performs. This episode was very scary and dramatic to watch. Well Done BBC.
Elizabeth on November 2nd, 2008
Oh, but I'll have to agree with this bit, though: "Merlin and Arthur could well be the latest incarnation of The Fast Show's Ted and Ralph." Yes. Only not as interesting. Perhaps this show should consider a surprise reveal that Arthur is actually madly in love with Merlin or vice versa. It's not like the writers seem to have any intention in developing Morgana and Gwen, so why not? Pair Arthur and Merlin up and have it done with. I still won't be watching it, but it'll be a brave move.
Elizabeth on November 2nd, 2008
God, I think I'll never agree with these reviews. I thought this episode was boring. Didn't care for the guest stars, found the running stock joke unfunny and stale, remained underwhelmed by Morgan's Merlin, and rolled my eyes when things played out exactly like they always do: Arthur in peril, Merlin saving him. I've had enough.
graham lanfear, westbury wiltshire on November 1st, 2008
i thought it was amzaing it does what its says on the book, full of spells and magic and it was great family entertainment i loved it best episode yet.
Andrew, Gateshead on November 1st, 2008
Another great episode and certainly in the stronger end of it's run so far. I would say that you knocking the "come and stay" plot idea is a perhaps a little harsh - how exciting would an episode be where a visitor arrived and had a very pleasant time for 45mins? People must come and go all the time - we just get to see the fun ones....