Your responses
michelle lawrence, wolverhampton, on August 2nd, 2009
in response to all the negative comments ~ if you felt it was that bad all you had to do was reach for the remote. for me OMG i was on the edge of my seat for all 5 nights. it was a rollercoaster of emotions for me, i laughed, cried, sighed, was touched, scared and so many other emotions flashed through me. Yes it was a shame to see the hub go ~ but hey just means we get a bigger and better one. lets look on the bright side. yes we'll miss ianto, but we'll miss tosh and owen too, and who knows doesn't it leave the way open for some new and exciting new up and coming actor??? ok now ~ quatermass ~ when was it 30 years ago ??? so who cares a lot of the torchwood fans are too young to remember i am my son is as i said at the begining you only had to press your remote once if you didn't like it and no one made you return for any of the following episode so i say WELL DONE BBC and roll on the next series, you've out done yourselves keep it up that only leaves me to say John Barrowman ~ your a ledgend, long may you reign, i love your portrail of Jack
amy clarke, south east on July 23rd, 2009
brill episode ax
Matt on July 23rd, 2009
Utterly astonishing! A series I shall not forget! Children of Earth as a whole was (I think) the finest moment in the whole dr.who universe and continueum. All I can say is well done Davis, well done Lyne and well done Torchwood. "Your not eating raw potatos!"
debra on July 22nd, 2009
i love torchwood and want it to come back but why did iahntohave to be killed off they got rid of owen and toshiko why why why dont get rid of any more or we will have to call it what wood
Sandy on July 21st, 2009
Did I just watch Torchwood or Quatermass 4? I agree, the idea was brilliant - in 1979 when it first aired. Good Lord, kill off one of the two most popular actors on the series, conveniently introduce a daughter and grandson so the grandson can be sacrificed, turn Capt Jack upside down and totally away from the past two seasons, disembowel Torchwood, and you have Children of Earth. I could ride Ianto's tractor through the plot holes and contrivances. Someone please hit the reset button and give us back Torchwood, the real Jack and Ianto.
Chris Allen, Sheffield on July 17th, 2009
"The concept of the 456 wanting to use the world's children to get their latest narcotic hit is genius and terrifying to contemplate" I'm sure the late Nigel Kneale (Quatermass Conclusion, 1979) would have appreciated your praise, since he used the same idea 30 years ago.
John, England on July 17th, 2009
Suddenly, the immortal, centuries-old unkillable guy has descendents. Oh, and by a miraculous and awesome coincidence, his grandson just happens to be of the right age for the part of sacrificial virgin. Wow, what a stroke of luck that was. I mean, he might have had to go out and snatch some other poor family's pride and joy had he not just happened to conveniently have his own right there. Right where he needed it. Poor writing. Trite and obvious. All the tension of an advert for kitchen tissues. And as original as yet another "Buffy" clone. That no one thought of the obvious attack method until the very last possible moment was slightly unlikely. But not quite as unlikely as the Captain just happening to have a conveniently appealing, never-before mentioned family. The poorest TW yet.
amanda, Glasgow on July 17th, 2009
It was astonishing. Truly. I could take it or leave it before this series but these 5 episodes were some of the most powerful tv i've seen for many many months.
Charlie, London on July 17th, 2009
I thought this series was absolutely brilliant. I am so glad they didn't white wash issues and make everything rosy. I thought there were real issues of todays world shown in this series, such as when the children are being chased across a muddy field by soldiers, Gwen carrying the little girl - how many children go through terryfying experiences like that every day in war torn countries, and how many parents live with the agonising reality of not being able to protect their children (Jack and his Daughter). The comments saying they are dissapointed that Jack was made unlikeable - that's who he is. He's experienced the universe through centuries of time, trying to find his place, only ever fitting in for so long before it's runied and he has to move on. This series really made me think of things on a much broader scale, thought provoking drama. Not just passive viewing. Excellent!
Joe, Croydon on July 16th, 2009
Absolutely brilliant! However, I'm posting this in response to Katie from London's post on 14th July: "it was never explained why Jack had to choose to kill his own grandson to save the world- why not some random child??" Because he did what was necessary, and unlike the politicians who were willing to sacrifice any children but their own, Jack was willing to make that heartbreaking sacrifice. Totally selfless heroism.
Jamie, Langley on July 16th, 2009
I was a big fan of Torchwood before this season and becoming even a bigger fan before the final episode of this season. However since seeing the finale I can state hand on heart that it was the worst episode I have ever seen. First of all they place an entire season in one week, then they destroy the entire team. It was like a last grasp at getting an audience enthralled and then taking away that which grabbed them in the first place.
kirsty southampton on July 16th, 2009
Im distraught torchwood is over but what a way to end it. It just shows Russel T Davies can do good stuff lets hope David Tennant gets a good exit and who knows Jack and the Doctor may meet again.
Cameron Angel Brooks on July 15th, 2009
I Loved Torchwood And Hate 2 See It Goo.... Bring Back Doctor Who To Keep Mi satisfied. Love Cameron x
William - France on July 15th, 2009
Cannot understand the highly negative reactions to this brilliant series 3. "Why didn't...?" What people seem to forget is that drama is about flawed people who make mistakes. Try rewriting this series eliminating all the mistakes and you have a 5 minute story instead of the 5 hours which rate amongst the greatest ever seen on television. Peter Capaldi must get an award for his performance in this. The shaking hand as he took the gun from the case turned what could have been tacky melodrama into heart-breaking reality. And just look at Jack's eyes as he sacrifices his grandson. Real emotion in there. Once again well done to the entire team for a truely memorable piece of television. JACK WILL BE BACK!
Katie, London on July 14th, 2009
It was undoubtedly fantastic television- brilliantly executed by both the director and the leads. But some of the decisions I really have to disagree with. As a fan, I was so expectant and joyous at the return of a series I hold so dearly- why oh why did they have to kill Ianto and to essentially destroy the series...?? The hub is gone, Gwen's pregnant and Jack is seemingly too distraught to continue. I am so gutted that they would wrap it up in this way, although I do understand the difficulties involved in Jack being immortal and those around him not being so. It just seemed like they wanted to kill off the series and wrap it up neatly at the end, but it was never explained why Jack had to choose to kill his own grandson to save the world- why not some random child?? Now Jack has lost everything, even if it was a difficult decision (which was depicted brilliantly). I personally found Jack to be quite unlikeable during these final episodes as we found out what he'd done in 1965 and then to kill his own grandson. I'm still pretty devastated over the ending of the series, and especially Ianto's death. If they bring it back (which doesn't seem likely), it has lost some of its appeal. I doubt I'm the only one who feels like this.
teestee, prestwick on July 14th, 2009
Pure event television. An example of what the BBC is best at, when it puts its mind to it. Still thinking about it, even days afterwards. Ianto's death is lingering long after the credits have rolled. Seismic!
Doc on July 14th, 2009
It was very good (for British television). Shame it ended the way it did though as I quite liked the older format of "alien of the week". The Americans seem to get it right in terms of having a story each week but having some kind of arc over the length of a series (e.g. Supernatural). I hope they do more but go back to the slightly older format of one a week.
rosie on July 14th, 2009
poor ending. programme kept me watching it all week only to be disappointed by the rushed ending. it was like they hadnt worked it out before they started
Debbie Yorkshire on July 14th, 2009
Absolutely superb both me and husband were hooked. Cried my eyes out at certain points but what brilliant writing! Well done. Can't wait to see what they come up with next.
Steve Saul, Brighton on July 14th, 2009
T'was it not a tad insensitive Gwen recording a vox pop about "the end of the world" while surrounded by a group of terrified children she's supposed to be protecting? Why did she do it? Other than it made a great teaser for Episode 5? Other than that one complaint this was a classic piece of television drama... genre or otherwise.
Charles Stone - Willenhall, West Midlands on July 14th, 2009
Easily the best production I have seen in ages - just when I thought television was dead. I completely agree with Ben Rawson-Jones article in every respect. Cheers to both Author and program arrangers for producing a program which gripped me from start to finish - that's a first for a long, long time! More of this kind, please.
Tony Wesley, Sutton Coldfield on July 14th, 2009
I can't remember the last time that a TV program or film had me loterally sitting on the edge of my seat -continually, just couldn't wait for the next 5 minutes. Russsell T. Davies is such an amazing writer - what an imagination!!
Daniel Erskine on July 14th, 2009
All week you have been peeving me with your harsh review of the best of the five - Day 2 and blatently dissing what was the were the nest parts of the episodes....then after the awful, criminally revolting, destruction of torchwood that was episode 5 i read - terrible, alsoubtly terribe im thinking finally...this man has found...sence... then i continued to read... You must seriously be demoted and have someone with have taste start reviewing these sci-fi shows because you are getting on my last nerve Ben Rawson-Jones!!!!!
sara scotland on July 14th, 2009
give it up do the right thing like robin hood leave it at that no more please
NoMoreBeatbox on July 14th, 2009
To be honest, I thought it was largely hammy and melodramatic, rather like a pantomime in some ways. I will say that it was compelling enough to watch right until the very end, which is no mean feat these days, but I felt let down by the final section - reminded me of those Star Trek Next Gen episodes where the scene was labouriously set for 40 minutes and then everything resolved and 'made so' in the last 4 minutes. Great idea and I really wanted to like it, but the execution let it down for me (like so often happens in its Dr Who sibling). :(
Ian, London on July 13th, 2009
Unmissable. I was glued to the set from the beginning. I was so pleased they actually gave Ianto something to do this season as he's been very underused... So was very disappointed to see him killed off. So what a new team all round for season 4? Well done everyone but boo-hiss for killing Ianto!
Angus, Glossop. on July 13th, 2009
After such a fantastic first 4 episodes I was left bewildered by Capt Jacks lack of enthusiasm or ideas in episode 5. I felt he had given up, and when it was sugested that he used his own grandson to defeat the 456 he did it too easily. Yes there was the emotion and guilt afterwards but I think he would have been more torn before the event. But the one key thing that ruined it for me is that Jack would not have made that decision, because the kids were not going to be killed. They were hooked up to the 456 and who knows whether they could be recovered. What we saw was Jack kill his own grandson to save the millions of children that weren't going to die anyway. I shall probably block this out of my memory by the time the next series comes around because I could not trust Capt Jack with the future of earth if he makes the wrong decisions for totally the wrong, unbelievable, reasons.
Jaz from Leicester on July 13th, 2009
Wowee it was amazing. It hit all the right buttons for me, I think it was the first time that I have ever laughed, been angry, cried, cursed, and warm and fuzzy, in one single thing. So WELL DONE!!
Rebecca, Hampshire on July 13th, 2009
John Barrowman is simply incredible.
battybern Tenbury on July 13th, 2009
the series was overstretched and the final gave the impression that Russell had run out of ideas and just wanted to close the series and get out for a drink Shame as he has written some brilliant story-lines
Heather, Buckingham on July 13th, 2009
I am still haunted by the final episode. I know its fiction, but it brought out some terrifying questions - what would we each do in that situation? John Barrowman was fantastic as ever and I found it totally unmissable. I am devastated that we now have to wait for another series. Make it soon!
saks london on July 13th, 2009
emotional rollercoaster ride. fantastic! out of this world and sad! morre pls!
Sarah on July 13th, 2009
Day Five was the saddest of all, the fact that Jack had to kill his own grandson was the worst. Also Gwen on the run with all those children. BBC did a good job, but i think killing Ianto was a bad idea, since many people love Ianto so much! It was a good death though! Loved it. Hope there is a series 4. And i hope Jack now appears in Doctor Who's next series!
A Mark,Birmingham on July 13th, 2009
As a whole, the mini-series was good, but the final episode in particular was weak and, I found, lacking. Then again, RTD has never been particularly good at writing brilliant finales.
Jakx Hampshire UK on July 13th, 2009
Shocked and saddened as I am at Ianto`s death, I must congratulate the BBC, RTD and of course John Barrowman for such a riviting 5 days. I was also saddened at the apparent back peddling of the relationship between Jack and Ianto. Previously it was a mutual thing, but this epic made it seem as if it was simply a late schoolboy crush that Ianto had on Jack. But that is/was my only gripe. Here`s hoping for series 4.
A Patel west midlands on July 13th, 2009
Luved it, It gud to see story lines where heros have their demons, and life is not all happily ever after. This series is up there with "They keep killing Suzie". Torchwood has some of the most imaginative well written scripts. Keep up the gud work.
Lee, York on July 13th, 2009
Loved it from start to finish, Torchwood has really come into it's own with this 5 nighter. There will be a series 4 i have no doubt, the ratings have been stellar for this. Just one little niggle and it is only a teeny one but what is stopping the 456 from returning to earth and destroying it. They only killed one creature, maybe it may come up in series 4. Five fantastic nights all the same.
Alex, Leicestershire on July 13th, 2009
What a disappointing end! It was going all fantasticly well up until Day 5 where it just failed totally as a Sci-Fi show. It was all just a drama, too many soppy deaths. We're all forgetting that this is meant to be Sci-Fi not a soap. Solving the problem in 2 minutes by pressing a few buttons was a massive anti-climax. When will Russell T Davies learn that Torchwood and Doctor Who are not soaps or dramas? He's done it to Dr. Who, now to Torchwood. I'm glad he's leaving to be honest.
Carole Ellis, Gloucester on July 13th, 2009
The only people I liked on this show was the original Capt Jack and Capt John played wonderfully well by James Marsters. I wish we could have the adventures of these two characters now Capt Jack has gone offworld. I found the acting of the original team far too forced. I thought Eve Myles acted as though she thought she was Ellen Ripley!
Jude, Central Scotland on July 13th, 2009
First I loved every second of it even the bits I hated. Don't know how many of you are aware of the nastiness James Moran has had to face on twitter and his blog (the pen is mightier than the spork) but it's been truly horrible. I waited with barely controlled excitement for the next TW and hope by the time it comes round a small portion of fandom will have grown up and remembered their manners