Which would cause the biggest controversary - The X Factor

Tye111 · 21-11-2009, 13:42

After the controversary that occured after Lucie was booted out over the twins! It got me thinking which of these scenarios would cause the most controversary amongst fans and would any of them cause the same reaction as Lucie's exit did.

Lloyd vs Jedward with Lloyd Leaving
Danyl vs Jedward with Danyl leaving
Joe vs Jedward with Joe leaving
Stacie vs Jedward with Stacie leaving
Olly vs Jedward with Olly leaving

Sib69 · 21-11-2009, 13:43

any of them apart from the first one

eta: actually, stacey going. because dannii said she would quit if the twins got further than stacey

munta · 21-11-2009, 13:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sib69

any of them apart from the first one

Had to laugh at that one

Sib69 · 21-11-2009, 13:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by munta

Had to laugh at that one

lol. well, it's true

Faria262 · 21-11-2009, 13:55

I think if Jedward left over Lloyd, there would be more controversy than vice versa - ev3en if I caused most of it!

Not sure which would be the most dramatic otherwise, maybe Stacey if Dannii's serious, don'think Danyl would be as much of a shock as he's had bad press this week and been in the bottom 2 before

xxxx

upintheskylfc · 21-11-2009, 14:04

Joe vs Jedward with Joe leaving

Cheryl would be p!ssed

Eurostar · 21-11-2009, 14:06

None of them for me ; the only outrage would be Jedward being voted off against one of those talentless bores

MARTYM8 · 21-11-2009, 14:06

Stacey vs Olly bottom 2.

Lizzy11268 · 21-11-2009, 14:07

The only thing that will shock me on Sunday, is if Olly or Stacey were to go home. And even then it would only be mild shock which would wear off in about 5 minutes.

Despite what is said, it is really unpredictable this year. Thats what makes it interesting.

neelia · 21-11-2009, 14:34

Lloyd staying over anyone really.

Although I want Olly and Joe to stay to the end (and Jedward for the laugh). I get more annoyed by someone leaving unfairly, than who actually leaves.

GetMeOuttaHere · 21-11-2009, 14:39

Biggest controversy would be (as someone on another thread suggested) if Danyl didn't sing the song he's meant to. Mind you that would be career suicide, he'd never get another singing gig again. It would certainly be two fingers up to SC.

Anyway on topic, this show is now built on controversy and not talent.

Animex3 · 21-11-2009, 14:42

The one that makes Simon the most money.

lea27 · 21-11-2009, 14:55

Id say the twins staying over Stacey or Olly.

I think Olly has this now although he would only be the best of an average bunch.

Kimmoiserie · 21-11-2009, 15:01

[quote=GetMeOuttaHere;36808308]Biggest controversy would be (as someone on another thread suggested) if Danyl didn't sing the song he's meant to. Mind you that would be career suicide, he'd never get another singing gig again. It would certainly be two fingers up to SC.
QUOTE]

Getme,

I kind of think that Danyl has committed career Hari Kiri to the point where anything else would be flogging a horse that's been dead for weeks, sent to the glue factory, turned into UHU.

I don't think he did it all by himself, but from the sound of it he's done himself no favours whatsoever.

21-11-2009, 13:42	#1
Tye111 Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2009 Posts: 1,256	Which would cause the biggest controversary After the controversary that occured after Lucie was booted out over the twins! It got me thinking which of these scenarios would cause the most controversary amongst fans and would any of them cause the same reaction as Lucie's exit did. Lloyd vs Jedward with Lloyd Leaving Danyl vs Jedward with Danyl leaving Joe vs Jedward with Joe leaving Stacie vs Jedward with Stacie leaving Olly vs Jedward with Olly leaving

21-11-2009, 13:43	#2
Sib69 Forum Member Join Date: Jan 2008 Gender: Female Location: Jedward Land :) Services: John & Edward & Rafa Nadal :P Posts: 5,915	any of them apart from the first one eta: actually, stacey going. because dannii said she would quit if the twins got further than stacey

21-11-2009, 13:55	#5
Faria262 Forum Member Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: AMJO - With Love! xxxx Services: JLS - NO AIR DUET ON DEMAND!!!! Posts: 4,221	I think if Jedward left over Lloyd, there would be more controversy than vice versa - ev3en if I caused most of it! Not sure which would be the most dramatic otherwise, maybe Stacey if Dannii's serious, don'think Danyl would be as much of a shock as he's had bad press this week and been in the bottom 2 before xxxx

21-11-2009, 14:04	#6
upintheskylfc Forum Member Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Liverpool Services: F*** you I wont do what ya tell me Posts: 1,278	Joe vs Jedward with Joe leaving Cheryl would be p!ssed

21-11-2009, 14:06	#7
Eurostar Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2002 Gender: Male Location: Dublin Posts: 10,847	None of them for me ; the only outrage would be Jedward being voted off against one of those talentless bores

21-11-2009, 14:06	#8
MARTYM8 Forum Member Join Date: Jun 2006 Posts: 9,918	Stacey vs Olly bottom 2.

21-11-2009, 14:07	#9
Lizzy11268 Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Posts: 7,508	The only thing that will shock me on Sunday, is if Olly or Stacey were to go home. And even then it would only be mild shock which would wear off in about 5 minutes. Despite what is said, it is really unpredictable this year. Thats what makes it interesting.

21-11-2009, 14:34	#10
neelia Forum Member Join Date: Jul 2005 Services: Persuing my exclusively Classical dreams on Broadway :) Posts: 10,630	Lloyd staying over anyone really. Although I want Olly and Joe to stay to the end (and Jedward for the laugh). I get more annoyed by someone leaving unfairly, than who actually leaves.

21-11-2009, 14:39	#11
GetMeOuttaHere Forum Member Join Date: Mar 2008 Gender: Female Location: CBeebies Services: Teaching you to singalong to Timmy Time Baahh Posts: 8,949	Biggest controversy would be (as someone on another thread suggested) if Danyl didn't sing the song he's meant to. Mind you that would be career suicide, he'd never get another singing gig again. It would certainly be two fingers up to SC. Anyway on topic, this show is now built on controversy and not talent.

21-11-2009, 14:42	#12
Animex3 Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2009 Posts: 238	The one that makes Simon the most money.

21-11-2009, 14:55	#13
lea27 Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 5,917	Id say the twins staying over Stacey or Olly. I think Olly has this now although he would only be the best of an average bunch.

21-11-2009, 15:01	#14
Kimmoiserie Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 314	[quote=GetMeOuttaHere;36808308]Biggest controversy would be (as someone on another thread suggested) if Danyl didn't sing the song he's meant to. Mind you that would be career suicide, he'd never get another singing gig again. It would certainly be two fingers up to SC. QUOTE] Getme, I kind of think that Danyl has committed career Hari Kiri to the point where anything else would be flogging a horse that's been dead for weeks, sent to the glue factory, turned into UHU. I don't think he did it all by himself, but from the sound of it he's done himself no favours whatsoever.