About A Girl : Keisha vs Jade - Music

garyessex · 26-09-2009, 11:44

Featuring Keisha
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kgj03wyq_IQ

Featuring Jade
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Y859QTm_S0

Whats better?

FIGHT!

WLB · 26-09-2009, 11:47

I think its a really strong song in both versions.

The big difference i think is that Jades voice seems to blend in with the other two better than Keishas did, as hers always stood out a bit over the others. However, to some extent (as in it worked with some songs, and not others), the difference of her voices sometimes made the Sugababes sounds distinct from other groups.

LoveBug. · 26-09-2009, 11:51

Erm, Keisha.

Gold_Fish · 26-09-2009, 11:52

Pretty awful no matter who sings it, to be honest.

LewisUK · 26-09-2009, 11:55

Jade!

Patrick2772 · 26-09-2009, 12:02

The song is very dull, but Jade's beginning is slightly more interesting.

I can't tell who sings where in what parts, apart from the "Red One, Sugababes" bit.

Ethereal · 26-09-2009, 12:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by Patrick2772

The song is very dull, but Jade's beginning is slightly more interesting.

I can't tell who sings where in what parts, apart from the "Red One, Sugababes" bit.

Heidi is the first verse.
Jade is the pre-chorus and chorus.
Amelle is the second verse.
Heidi and Amelle do the bridge.

funkycub · 26-09-2009, 12:08

Positive is I like Jades better. The Negative is although better her voice is not as distinctive. I struggle to know the difference between Jade and Heidi on the track

For a track to come in on it was a good one as I am not sure it suited Keisha's voice.

Patrick2772 · 26-09-2009, 12:16

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ethereal

Heidi is the first verse.
Jade is the pre-chorus and chorus.
Amelle is the second verse.
Heidi and Amelle do the bridge.

Okay, thank you!

I'm surprised that I think Jade's is better. Keisha's is a bit more distinctive, but Jade seems to put more emphasis into it.

Still, dull song.

LemonadeMan · 26-09-2009, 12:25

I don't think it's a very good track either way but I prefer the Keisha version.

tomi-08 · 26-09-2009, 12:26

I prefer the Jade version after a few more listens.

molybecks · 26-09-2009, 12:38

I like both versions actually.

RocaBoi18 · 26-09-2009, 13:26

Keisha's by far...Jade's sounds really cheap when she pronounces 'GIRL' and 'WORLD'.

musicdude · 26-09-2009, 13:40

Who sings the Red One, Sugababes bit?

dd68 · 26-09-2009, 13:44

Both versions good, will miss Keishas voice though

daisybee · 26-09-2009, 13:55

Jade's

hadn't heard Keisha's before but finding it hard to swap over now both really good versions but think i prefer Jade's that bit more

caren197 · 26-09-2009, 14:47

Keisha...this doesn't even sound like the sugababes

superyeah · 26-09-2009, 14:54

Love both versions but it has to be:

JADE'S

Sam - Fan · 26-09-2009, 15:02

Like both but another one for Jade's.

Leeah · 26-09-2009, 15:04

Keisha's

Pop_Art · 26-09-2009, 15:08

Jade's if I'm being honest. Someone made a good point elsewhere. Jade's diction is far great than that of Keisha's.

I love the nickname Keisha The Screecher that is going around youtube

musicdude · 26-09-2009, 15:14

Quote:

Originally Posted by musicdude

Who sings the Red One, Sugababes bit?

Uhh, rudeness

Either version is good

Makson · 26-09-2009, 15:34

Keisha's version packs more "oomph" I feel.
Jade's chorus sounds too slow as if she is making sure to get all the words in and pronounce them properly. You can tell she sounds uncomfortable which isn't a surprise as it seems she joined the group on a whim. She'll settle down though and at least people won't be able to compare her voice to Keisha's on any other of the new album's tracks.
I mean there is absolutely no doubt that Jade has a good voice but I feel she is more of a solo artist and Keisha's voice is more suited to being in a group. Not sure she can cut it on her own. I think her best best would be to go and form a new group.

mikey86uk · 26-09-2009, 16:03

cant really tell much difference

iHelix · 26-09-2009, 17:10

Jade's version sounds better to me. I never rated Keishas voice that much if I'm honest. I don't rate Amelle's either.

However, with Keisha, I always knew what bits she was singing because her voice sounds different to the other two. But now, if I didn't already know which parts Jade would be singing, I wouldn't be able to tell the difference at all.

26-09-2009, 11:44	#1
garyessex Forum Member Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 2,139	About A Girl : Keisha vs Jade Featuring Keisha http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kgj03wyq_IQ Featuring Jade http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Y859QTm_S0 Whats better? FIGHT!

26-09-2009, 11:47	#2
WLB Forum Member Join Date: Mar 2004 Posts: 457	I think its a really strong song in both versions. The big difference i think is that Jades voice seems to blend in with the other two better than Keishas did, as hers always stood out a bit over the others. However, to some extent (as in it worked with some songs, and not others), the difference of her voices sometimes made the Sugababes sounds distinct from other groups.

26-09-2009, 11:51	#3
LoveBug. Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Gender: Female Services: Where them girls talkin trash at? Where they at? ♥ Posts: 2,708	Erm, Keisha.

26-09-2009, 11:52	#4
Gold_Fish Forum Member Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 1,089	Pretty awful no matter who sings it, to be honest.

26-09-2009, 11:55	#5
LewisUK Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2008 Gender: Male Location: Cardiff Posts: 654	Jade!

26-09-2009, 12:02	#6
Patrick2772 Forum Member Join Date: Mar 2009 Posts: 1,903	The song is very dull, but Jade's beginning is slightly more interesting. I can't tell who sings where in what parts, apart from the "Red One, Sugababes" bit.

26-09-2009, 12:08	#8
funkycub Forum Member Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Typing with one hand. probably Posts: 3,806	Positive is I like Jades better. The Negative is although better her voice is not as distinctive. I struggle to know the difference between Jade and Heidi on the track For a track to come in on it was a good one as I am not sure it suited Keisha's voice.

26-09-2009, 12:25	#10
LemonadeMan Forum Member Join Date: May 2007 Posts: 1,381	I don't think it's a very good track either way but I prefer the Keisha version.

26-09-2009, 12:26	#11
tomi-08 Forum Member Join Date: Dec 2008 Gender: Male Location: Ruth Lorenzo Services: Stacey Solomon Posts: 7,395	I prefer the Jade version after a few more listens.

26-09-2009, 12:38	#12
molybecks Forum Member Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Walford. Services: Eastenders/...Hollyoaks...\Lady Gaga<3/..Doctor Who../ :D Posts: 5,001	I like both versions actually.

26-09-2009, 13:26	#13
RocaBoi18 Forum Member Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Lincoln Services: CiCi, C. Breezy, LeLe, JT, Bey and Kid Cudi. Posts: 2,486	Keisha's by far...Jade's sounds really cheap when she pronounces 'GIRL' and 'WORLD'.

26-09-2009, 13:40	#14
musicdude Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2009 Posts: 2,727	Who sings the Red One, Sugababes bit?

26-09-2009, 13:44	#15
dd68 Forum Member Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: London Services: Sky+ Posts: 5,814	Both versions good, will miss Keishas voice though

26-09-2009, 13:55	#16
daisybee Forum Member Join Date: Dec 2006 Posts: 6,260	Jade's hadn't heard Keisha's before but finding it hard to swap over now both really good versions but think i prefer Jade's that bit more

26-09-2009, 14:47	#17
caren197 Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Posts: 775	Keisha...this doesn't even sound like the sugababes

26-09-2009, 14:54	#18
superyeah Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: The X Factor studio Services: X Factor: Stacey, Lucie, Miss Frank FTW!! Posts: 3,379 Blog Entries: 20	Love both versions but it has to be: JADE'S

26-09-2009, 15:02	#19
Sam - Fan Inactive Member Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Love Samantha Janus/Womack Posts: 306	Like both but another one for Jade's.

26-09-2009, 15:04	#20
Leeah Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2007 Posts: 5,736	Keisha's

26-09-2009, 15:08	#21
Pop_Art Forum Member Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: England Services: Sky+ Posts: 1,639	Jade's if I'm being honest. Someone made a good point elsewhere. Jade's diction is far great than that of Keisha's. I love the nickname Keisha The Screecher that is going around youtube

26-09-2009, 15:34	#23
Makson Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2007 Posts: 1,262	Keisha's version packs more "oomph" I feel. Jade's chorus sounds too slow as if she is making sure to get all the words in and pronounce them properly. You can tell she sounds uncomfortable which isn't a surprise as it seems she joined the group on a whim. She'll settle down though and at least people won't be able to compare her voice to Keisha's on any other of the new album's tracks. I mean there is absolutely no doubt that Jade has a good voice but I feel she is more of a solo artist and Keisha's voice is more suited to being in a group. Not sure she can cut it on her own. I think her best best would be to go and form a new group.

26-09-2009, 16:03	#24
mikey86uk Forum Member Join Date: Feb 2005 Gender: Male Location: England Posts: 3,123	cant really tell much difference

26-09-2009, 17:10	#25
iHelix Forum Member Join Date: Dec 2008 Gender: Male Location: Lancashire Services: twitter.com/steosphere Posts: 4,750	Jade's version sounds better to me. I never rated Keishas voice that much if I'm honest. I don't rate Amelle's either. However, with Keisha, I always knew what bits she was singing because her voice sounds different to the other two. But now, if I didn't already know which parts Jade would be singing, I wouldn't be able to tell the difference at all.