Rank the judges in terms of your favourite (last year vs this year) - The X Factor

Abigail88 · 08-11-2009, 14:48

Last year:

Cheryl
Simon
Dannii
Louis

This year:

Dannii
Cheryl
Louis
Simon

meglosmurmurs · 08-11-2009, 15:28

Interesting topic.

Last year:
Cheryl
Dannii
Simon
Louis

This year:
Dannii
Cheryl
Simon
Louis

Xfactorfan94 · 08-11-2009, 15:34

Last Year;

Cheryl
Simon
Louis
Dannii

(Just didn't get Dannii last year)

This Year;

Dannii
Simon
Cheryl
Louis

(Think he's disillusional (sp?)

)

Chisato Geeste · 08-11-2009, 15:36

Last Year

Dannii
Simon
Cheryl
Louis

This Year

Dannii
Louis
Cheryl
Simon

Roamed · 08-11-2009, 15:38

Last Year:

Simon
Cheryl
Dannii
Louis

This Year:

Dannii
Simon
Louis
Cheryl

Blemished · 08-11-2009, 15:39

Last Year:

Simon
Dannii
Louis
Cheryl

This Year:

Dannii
Simon
Cheryl
Louis

WelshieRachel · 08-11-2009, 15:40

Last year:
Cheryl
Simon
Louis
Dannii

This year:
Cheryl
Louis
Dannii
Simon

Tina_UK · 08-11-2009, 15:40

Last year:
Cheryl
Dannii
Simon
Louis

This year:
Dannii
Cheryl
Simon
Louis

sHaK · 08-11-2009, 15:41

1. Dannii
2. Simon (Usually #1 every year, but he's been annoying me this year)
3. Cheryl
4. Louis (Moron)

kyri · 08-11-2009, 15:41

Last Year:

1. Louis
2. Simon
3. Danni
4. Cheryl

This year:

1. Louis
2. Simon
3. Danni
4. Cheryl

lovecat86 · 08-11-2009, 15:42

Last year:
Simon
Louis
Cheryl
Dannii

This year:
Dannii
Simon
Louis
Cheryl

All change

Louise1202 · 08-11-2009, 15:43

Last Year:

Simon
Cheryl
Dannii
Louis

This Year:

Dannii
Simon
Louis
Cheryl

-Jade" · 08-11-2009, 15:45

Last year:
Dannii
Simon
Cheryl
Louis

This year:
Dannii
Louis
Simon
Cheryl

ribtickle · 08-11-2009, 15:47

Last year

Cheryl
Simon
Louis
Dannii

This year

Cheryl Coleslaw
Looby Lou
Simone 'Cig'noret
Dannii Mynose

panda_eyes · 08-11-2009, 15:50

Last year

Dannii + Cheryl
Simon (not far behind)
Louis

This year
Dannii

Cheryl
Louis

Simon (really getting on my nerves this year)

Cone · 08-11-2009, 15:55

Last year:

Simon
Louis
Cheryl
Dannii

This Year:
Louis
Dannii
Simon
Cheryl

DogmaLoki · 08-11-2009, 15:57

Last Year:

1) Simon
2) Cheryl
3) Dannii
4) Louis

This year:

1) Dannii
2) Simon
3) Cheryl
4) Louis

Sulty · 08-11-2009, 15:58

Last year:
Dannii
Cheryl
Simon
Louis

This year:
Dannii
Louis+Simon+Cheryl <--- they've all got their good moments and their bad ones ^^

DogmaLoki · 08-11-2009, 15:58

Quote:

Originally Posted by Louise1202

Last Year:

Simon
Cheryl
Dannii
Louis

This Year:

Dannii
Simon
Louis
Cheryl

We are almost in complete agreement.

It's a pity we can't work out some sort of scheme where we can all be compared!

*coco* · 08-11-2009, 16:00

Last year:
Dannii
Simon
Cheryl
Louis

This Year:
Dannii
Louis
Cheryl
Simon

tina. · 08-11-2009, 16:01

Last year:
Cheryl
Simon
Louis
Dannii

This year:
Dannii
Simon
Louis
Cheryl

princesss321 · 08-11-2009, 16:01

Last year:

Cheryl
Simon
Dannii
Louis

This year:

Dannii
Simon
Louis
Cheryl

spunk_1 · 08-11-2009, 16:02

Last year
Dannii
Simon
Cheryl
Lous

This year
Dannii
Louis
Simon
Cheryl

SlimSim · 08-11-2009, 16:04

LAST YEAR

Cheryl
Simon
Dannii
Louis

THIS YEAR

Dannii
Simon
Cheryl
Louis

Snozzcumber · 08-11-2009, 16:06

Last year:

Dannii
Simon
Louis
Cheryl

This year:

Dannii
Louis
Simon
Cheryl

Dannii's always seemed like the fairest and most dedicated of all the judges. She really takes her acts seriously.

Simon used to be funny and have some semblance of objectivity. This year he seems unnecessarily tetchy and all the standing ovations are just absurd when you consider he used to be viewed as hard to please. Far too partisan.

I've always liked Louis cheeky and irascible side, even if he can be irritating at times. I like the controversy and humour he brings to the show.

I just find Cheryl really predictable and dull. I don't even really dislike her - she just doesn't produce any reaction. I know all of them are prone to cliches and stock phrases, but it'll be a major shock to the system if Ms. Cole can ever make a positive comment without the words "D'you know what?" or "I thoroughly enjoyed".

08-11-2009, 14:48	#1
Abigail88 Forum Member Join Date: Jun 2009 Posts: 95	Rank the judges in terms of your favourite (last year vs this year) Last year: Cheryl Simon Dannii Louis This year: Dannii Cheryl Louis Simon

08-11-2009, 15:28	#2
meglosmurmurs Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2008 Location: The high end of low. Services: I hate what I have become to escape what I hated being. Posts: 3,116	Interesting topic. Last year: Cheryl Dannii Simon Louis This year: Dannii Cheryl Simon Louis

08-11-2009, 15:34	#3
Xfactorfan94 Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Posts: 65	Last Year; Cheryl Simon Louis Dannii (Just didn't get Dannii last year) This Year; Dannii Simon Cheryl Louis (Think he's disillusional (sp?) )

08-11-2009, 15:36	#4
Chisato Geeste Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Chair Posts: 14,392	Last Year Dannii Simon Cheryl Louis This Year Dannii Louis Cheryl Simon

08-11-2009, 15:38	#5
Roamed Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 480	Last Year: Simon Cheryl Dannii Louis This Year: Dannii Simon Louis Cheryl

08-11-2009, 15:39	#6
Blemished Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Gender: Female Location: Sheffield Services: Fernando Alonso ♥ Still going with the 'fro! • Gino & George :) Posts: 948	Last Year: Simon Dannii Louis Cheryl This Year: Dannii Simon Cheryl Louis

08-11-2009, 15:40	#7
WelshieRachel Forum Member Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Wales Services: Stephanie Beacham,Cheryl Cole & Frankie Sandford <3 Posts: 1,335	Last year: Cheryl Simon Louis Dannii This year: Cheryl Louis Dannii Simon

08-11-2009, 15:40	#8
Tina_UK Forum Member Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Manchester Posts: 2,095	Last year: Cheryl Dannii Simon Louis This year: Dannii Cheryl Simon Louis

08-11-2009, 15:41	#9
sHaK Forum Member Join Date: Jun 2005 Posts: 1,726	1. Dannii 2. Simon (Usually #1 every year, but he's been annoying me this year) 3. Cheryl 4. Louis (Moron)

08-11-2009, 15:41	#10
kyri Forum Member Join Date: Feb 2005 Gender: Not specified Services: Team Walsh ~ John and Edward Posts: 20,563	Last Year: 1. Louis 2. Simon 3. Danni 4. Cheryl This year: 1. Louis 2. Simon 3. Danni 4. Cheryl

08-11-2009, 15:42	#11
lovecat86 Forum Member Join Date: Jan 2007 Gender: Not specified Location: Warwickshire Services: Loves Jamie and John & Edward. Team WeDon'tCareWhoWins Posts: 5,864	Last year: Simon Louis Cheryl Dannii This year: Dannii Simon Louis Cheryl All change

08-11-2009, 15:43	#12
Louise1202 Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 116	Last Year: Simon Cheryl Dannii Louis This Year: Dannii Simon Louis Cheryl

08-11-2009, 15:45	#13
-Jade" Forum Member Join Date: Feb 2009 Gender: Female Location: AMJO :] Services: J&E<3 Posts: 3,506	Last year: Dannii Simon Cheryl Louis This year: Dannii Louis Simon Cheryl

08-11-2009, 15:47	#14
ribtickle Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2007 Posts: 2,459	Last year Cheryl Simon Louis Dannii This year Cheryl Coleslaw Looby Lou Simone 'Cig'noret Dannii Mynose

08-11-2009, 15:50	#15
panda_eyes Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: Middle of Nowhere Posts: 370	Last year Dannii + Cheryl Simon (not far behind) Louis This year Dannii Cheryl Louis Simon (really getting on my nerves this year)

08-11-2009, 15:55	#16
Cone Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Belfast Posts: 338	Last year: Simon Louis Cheryl Dannii This Year: Louis Dannii Simon Cheryl

08-11-2009, 15:57	#17
DogmaLoki Forum Member Join Date: Jul 2003 Services: Sky Digital, Tivo, PlusNet ADSL Posts: 698	Last Year: 1) Simon 2) Cheryl 3) Dannii 4) Louis This year: 1) Dannii 2) Simon 3) Cheryl 4) Louis

08-11-2009, 15:58	#18
Sulty Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 250	Last year: Dannii Cheryl Simon Louis This year: Dannii Louis+Simon+Cheryl <--- they've all got their good moments and their bad ones ^^

08-11-2009, 16:00	#20
coco Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Gender: Not specified Location: Team Minogue x Services: Stacey FTW!! <3 Posts: 969	Last year: Dannii Simon Cheryl Louis This Year: Dannii Louis Cheryl Simon

08-11-2009, 16:01	#21
tina. Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Luton, England Services: Sky+ Posts: 651	Last year: Cheryl Simon Louis Dannii This year: Dannii Simon Louis Cheryl

08-11-2009, 16:01	#22
princesss321 Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 46	Last year: Cheryl Simon Dannii Louis This year: Dannii Simon Louis Cheryl

08-11-2009, 16:02	#23
spunk_1 Forum Member Join Date: Dec 2008 Posts: 1,450	Last year Dannii Simon Cheryl Lous This year Dannii Louis Simon Cheryl

08-11-2009, 16:04	#24
SlimSim Forum Member Join Date: Jun 2009 Posts: 650	LAST YEAR Cheryl Simon Dannii Louis THIS YEAR Dannii Simon Cheryl Louis

08-11-2009, 16:06	#25
Snozzcumber Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2009 Gender: Female Location: Bath Haus of GaGa Services: The Beautiful, Dirty, Rich Posts: 556	Last year: Dannii Simon Louis Cheryl This year: Dannii Louis Simon Cheryl Dannii's always seemed like the fairest and most dedicated of all the judges. She really takes her acts seriously. Simon used to be funny and have some semblance of objectivity. This year he seems unnecessarily tetchy and all the standing ovations are just absurd when you consider he used to be viewed as hard to please. Far too partisan. I've always liked Louis cheeky and irascible side, even if he can be irritating at times. I like the controversy and humour he brings to the show. I just find Cheryl really predictable and dull. I don't even really dislike her - she just doesn't produce any reaction. I know all of them are prone to cliches and stock phrases, but it'll be a major shock to the system if Ms. Cole can ever make a positive comment without the words "D'you know what?" or "I thoroughly enjoyed".