Lucie Thought She Was Staying - The X Factor

slappers r us · 09-11-2009, 01:09

Lucie didnt seem as upset as other acts have by being in the bottom two

She sang her song very nicely smiling as though she was happy but without any kind of passion to the meaning of the song

When Dermot got the twins and her together she high fived the twins and stood smiling and IMO confident the judges would save her (I dont like the twins but they looked gutted)

She smiled at Louies choice knowing who he would vote for, she smiled at Dannii's choice, she didnt look worried when it came to Cheryl
Then came Simon and as soon as he said he got stick for going to deadlock last week Lucie knew he was going to let it go to deadlock again and her face fell, she realised it was up to the public and that she had a very good chance of leaving

Jamie and Danyl have both been accused of being cocky but when they were in the bottom two they were both crapping themselves that they would be going home, everyone who has found out they were in the bottom two have looked really worried and scared......all except Lucie

She took for granted that the judges would save her and it made her feel safe and IMO COCKY

BIG MISTAKE LUCIE

Mr Blonde · 09-11-2009, 01:11

Lucie looked like she was singing to an empty bar in a hotel in Benidorm...no passion...no determination...I thought she was on singstar...a complete contrast to John and Edward's eye of the tiger performance...

Honolulula · 09-11-2009, 01:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by slappers r us

Lucie didnt seem as upset as other acts have by being in the bottom two

She sang her song very nicely smiling as though she was happy but without any kind of passion to the meaning of the song

When Dermot got the twins and her together she high fived the twins and stood smiling and IMO confident the judges would save her (I dont like the twins but they looked gutted)

She smiled at Louies choice knowing who he would vote for, she smiled at Dannii's choice, she didnt look worried when it came to Cheryl
Then came Simon and as soon as he said he got stick for going to deadlock last week Lucie knew he was going to let it go to deadlock again and her face fell, she realised it was up to the public and that she had a very good chance of leaving

Jamie and Danyl have both been accused of being cocky but when they were in the bottom two they were both crapping themselves that they would be going home, everyone who has found out they were in the bottom two have looked really worried and scared......all except Lucie

She took for granted that the judges would save her and it made her feel safe and IMO COCKY

BIG MISTAKE LUCIE

cool story bro

Unigal07 · 09-11-2009, 01:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by slappers r us

Lucie didnt seem as upset as other acts have by being in the bottom two

She sang her song very nicely smiling as though she was happy but without any kind of passion to the meaning of the song

When Dermot got the twins and her together she high fived the twins and stood smiling and IMO confident the judges would save her (I dont like the twins but they looked gutted)

She smiled at Louies choice knowing who he would vote for, she smiled at Dannii's choice, she didnt look worried when it came to Cheryl
Then came Simon and as soon as he said he got stick for going to deadlock last week Lucie knew he was going to let it go to deadlock again and her face fell, she realised it was up to the public and that she had a very good chance of leaving

Jamie and Danyl have both been accused of being cocky but when they were in the bottom two they were both crapping themselves that they would be going home, everyone who has found out they were in the bottom two have looked really worried and scared......all except Lucie

She took for granted that the judges would save her and it made her feel safe and IMO COCKY

BIG MISTAKE LUCIE

You didn't see Xtra Factor then? Lucie has nothing but love for J&E. I do think she thought she had a good chance, let's face it she can belt a song and she has a lovely voice. THe judges have slated J&E throughout the competition and Simon is usually adamant that he goes on vocals.

Not surprised she was gutted when it went to deadlock. She came across so, so well on Xtra Factor. A very mature and decent young lady. I hope she goes far.

Billyyyyy · 09-11-2009, 01:13

What?

Stevie50001 · 09-11-2009, 01:13

Yep. I noticed this too.

Strictly_Irish · 09-11-2009, 01:15

I noticed that too but to be fair to the girl, we all thought the twins were out.

Thank God we were wrong.

Strictly_Irish · 09-11-2009, 01:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by Billyyyyy

What?

That was a big typo.

slappers r us · 09-11-2009, 01:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by Unigal07

You didn't see Xtra Factor then? Lucie has nothing but love for J&E. I do think she thought she had a good chance, let's face it she can belt a song and she has a lovely voice. THe judges have slated J&E throughout the competition and Simon is usually adamant that he goes on vocals.

Not surprised she was gutted when it went to deadlock. She came across so, so well on Xtra Factor. A very mature and decent young lady. I hope she goes far.

Ys I did see the Xtra Factor

She may have love for J&E but she still thought she had it in the bag and was safe

Blahgirl · 09-11-2009, 01:18

A decent singer getting the twins in the sing-off is like Man Utd getting Acrington Stanley in the FA cup you dont expect to lose.

thinkfun · 09-11-2009, 01:18

ya i agree with you however i think she thought that if theres anyone you want to be in the bottom 2 with its jedward.....lets be honest you dont want to be there with danyl or olly.....she must have thought that the judges were going to send home the act they have been giving out about for months not the act they said has found her niche and should be the last girl.........

Eurostar · 09-11-2009, 01:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blahgirl

A decent singer getting the twins in the sing-off is like Man Utd getting Acrington Stanley in the FA cup you dont expect to lose.

In terms of pulling in viewers and media interest,Jedward are Man Utd and Lucie is Accrington Stanley

KateH77 · 09-11-2009, 01:22

I thought the opposite tbh.

Since Yesterday · 09-11-2009, 01:22

Quote:

Originally Posted by slappers r us

Lucie didnt seem as upset as other acts have by being in the bottom two She sang her song very nicely smiling as though she was happy but without any kind of passion to the meaning of the song When Dermot got the twins and her together she high fived the twins and stood smiling and IMO confident the judges would save her (I dont like the twins but they looked gutted) She smiled at Louies choice knowing who he would vote for, she smiled at Dannii's choice, she didnt look worried when it came to Cheryl Then came Simon and as soon as he said he got stick for going to deadlock last week Lucie knew he was going to let it go to deadlock again and her face fell, she realised it was up to the public and that she had a very good chance of leaving Jamie and Danyl have both been accused of being cocky but when they were in the bottom two they were both crapping themselves that they would be going home, everyone who has found out they were in the bottom two have looked really worried and scared......all except Lucie She took for granted that the judges would save her and it made her feel safe and IMO COCKY BIG MISTAKE LUCIE

Absolute tosh. She seemed resigned to her fate, and did her best to go out with the best performance she could muster. She knew as well as any of us that Simon wouldn't have let it go to deadlock unless he was 100% confident that the twins were safe. So of course she reacted at that point - she didn't want to go, but she knew that it was inevitable as soon as he chickened out. She went to great lengths to support the twins immediately afterwards, rather than looking for attention. She proved herself to be mature beyond her years, and the absolute personification of graciousness and good sportsmanship.

lulu g · 09-11-2009, 01:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by slappers r us

Lucie didnt seem as upset as other acts have by being in the bottom two

She sang her song very nicely smiling as though she was happy but without any kind of passion to the meaning of the song

When Dermot got the twins and her together she high fived the twins and stood smiling and IMO confident the judges would save her (I dont like the twins but they looked gutted)

She smiled at Louies choice knowing who he would vote for, she smiled at Dannii's choice, she didnt look worried when it came to Cheryl
Then came Simon and as soon as he said he got stick for going to deadlock last week Lucie knew he was going to let it go to deadlock again and her face fell, she realised it was up to the public and that she had a very good chance of leaving

Jamie and Danyl have both been accused of being cocky but when they were in the bottom two they were both crapping themselves that they would be going home, everyone who has found out they were in the bottom two have looked really worried and scared......all except Lucie

She took for granted that the judges would save her and it made her feel safe and IMO COCKY

BIG MISTAKE LUCIE

Jamie hasn't been in the bottom two, has he?

Deerd · 09-11-2009, 01:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blahgirl

A decent singer getting the twins in the sing-off is like Man Utd getting Acrington Stanley in the FA cup you dont expect to lose.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eurostar

In terms of pulling in viewers and media interest,Jedward are Man Utd and Lucie is Accrington Stanley

Either way... Simon has his eye firmly on the 'gate'.

smartie 33 · 09-11-2009, 01:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by slappers r us

Lucie didnt seem as upset as other acts have by being in the bottom two

She sang her song very nicely smiling as though she was happy but without any kind of passion to the meaning of the song

When Dermot got the twins and her together she high fived the twins and stood smiling and IMO confident the judges would save her (I dont like the twins but they looked gutted)

She smiled at Louies choice knowing who he would vote for, she smiled at Dannii's choice, she didnt look worried when it came to Cheryl
Then came Simon and as soon as he said he got stick for going to deadlock last week Lucie knew he was going to let it go to deadlock again and her face fell, she realised it was up to the public and that she had a very good chance of leaving

Jamie and Danyl have both been accused of being cocky but when they were in the bottom two they were both crapping themselves that they would be going home, everyone who has found out they were in the bottom two have looked really worried and scared......all except Lucie

She took for granted that the judges would save her and it made her feel safe and IMO COCKY

BIG MISTAKE LUCIE

This is v true - I noticed that she was smiling through her performance like never before. She seemed completley unfazed. But I'm not sure if this really changed the outcome. SImon knows that it is Jedward who are cuasinginterest this series - not Lucie. So, unless she pulled out a performance like Ruth Lorenzo's bottom two performances last year, I have a feeling it would have gone to deadlock anyway.

slappers r us · 09-11-2009, 01:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by lulu g

Jamie hasn't been in the bottom two, has he?

I thought he had

Honolulula · 09-11-2009, 01:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by slappers r us

I thought he had

BIG MISTAKE

Mr Blonde · 09-11-2009, 01:46

Jamie has been in the bottom two performances every week...just not in the bottom two of voting...

slappers r us · 09-11-2009, 01:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr Blonde

Jamie has been in the bottom two performances every week...just not in the bottom two of voting...

Ooohhhh harsh

slappers r us · 09-11-2009, 01:52

Quote:

Originally Posted by Honolulula

BIG MISTAKE

Yes I agree

I admit to my mistakes

Billyyyyy · 09-11-2009, 01:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by Strictly_Irish

That was a big typo.

I know!
I misread *puts face in hand*

Hyooj · 09-11-2009, 01:59

Yeah, Lucy looked reasonably sanguine up to the point it went to deadlock. Then she looked really worried as if she was expecting to go home. She and/or Dannii made another big mistake with her bland sing-off song choice IMO, compounding the dreadful choice on Saturday which got her into the mess in the first place. If they'd picked a cracking song and she'd put some emotion into it, she could have made it virtually impossible for Simon not to kick out the twins.

BillyBoy7 · 09-11-2009, 02:28

At least Lucie SANG her sing off song.
Don't know who the voices were singing for the twins.

Lucie will have a career in singing.
Full marks to her for being so dignified, and Danni's remarks were fully justified.

Reinstate Lucie... Or this series is finished.

09-11-2009, 01:09	#1
slappers r us Forum Member Join Date: May 2005 Location: katmandoodieland Services: mountainsplashfarts Posts: 33,810	Lucie Thought She Was Staying Lucie didnt seem as upset as other acts have by being in the bottom two She sang her song very nicely smiling as though she was happy but without any kind of passion to the meaning of the song When Dermot got the twins and her together she high fived the twins and stood smiling and IMO confident the judges would save her (I dont like the twins but they looked gutted) She smiled at Louies choice knowing who he would vote for, she smiled at Dannii's choice, she didnt look worried when it came to Cheryl Then came Simon and as soon as he said he got stick for going to deadlock last week Lucie knew he was going to let it go to deadlock again and her face fell, she realised it was up to the public and that she had a very good chance of leaving Jamie and Danyl have both been accused of being cocky but when they were in the bottom two they were both crapping themselves that they would be going home, everyone who has found out they were in the bottom two have looked really worried and scared......all except Lucie She took for granted that the judges would save her and it made her feel safe and IMO COCKY BIG MISTAKE LUCIE

09-11-2009, 01:13	#5
Billyyyyy Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 628	What? Last edited by Billyyyyy : 09-11-2009 at 01:13. Reason: Typo.

09-11-2009, 01:11	#2
Mr Blonde Forum Member Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: London Posts: 9,220	Lucie looked like she was singing to an empty bar in a hotel in Benidorm...no passion...no determination...I thought she was on singstar...a complete contrast to John and Edward's eye of the tiger performance...

09-11-2009, 01:13	#6
Stevie50001 Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2007 Posts: 255	Yep. I noticed this too.

09-11-2009, 01:15	#7
Strictly_Irish Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2008 Services: Tom Chambers & Chris Hollins fan! John & Edward to win! :D x Posts: 4,783	I noticed that too but to be fair to the girl, we all thought the twins were out. Thank God we were wrong.

09-11-2009, 01:18	#10
Blahgirl Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 293	A decent singer getting the twins in the sing-off is like Man Utd getting Acrington Stanley in the FA cup you dont expect to lose.

09-11-2009, 01:18	#11
thinkfun Forum Member Join Date: May 2009 Posts: 1,195	ya i agree with you however i think she thought that if theres anyone you want to be in the bottom 2 with its jedward.....lets be honest you dont want to be there with danyl or olly.....she must have thought that the judges were going to send home the act they have been giving out about for months not the act they said has found her niche and should be the last girl.........

09-11-2009, 01:22	#13
KateH77 Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: Merseyside Services: Stacey/Jamie FTW! Posts: 794	I thought the opposite tbh.

09-11-2009, 01:46	#20
Mr Blonde Forum Member Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: London Posts: 9,220	Jamie has been in the bottom two performances every week...just not in the bottom two of voting...

09-11-2009, 01:59	#24
Hyooj Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Posts: 165	Yeah, Lucy looked reasonably sanguine up to the point it went to deadlock. Then she looked really worried as if she was expecting to go home. She and/or Dannii made another big mistake with her bland sing-off song choice IMO, compounding the dreadful choice on Saturday which got her into the mess in the first place. If they'd picked a cracking song and she'd put some emotion into it, she could have made it virtually impossible for Simon not to kick out the twins.

09-11-2009, 02:28	#25
BillyBoy7 Forum Member Join Date: Jul 2005 Posts: 35	At least Lucie SANG her sing off song. Don't know who the voices were singing for the twins. Lucie will have a career in singing. Full marks to her for being so dignified, and Danni's remarks were fully justified. Reinstate Lucie... Or this series is finished.