Gay Spy

Josh Holloway vs. Matthew McConaughey

Published Wednesday, Jun 18 2008, 10:40 BST | By Nick Levine | 112 comments
James McAvoy toppled Ewan McGregor in last week's all-Scottish contest, scoring 132 votes to his rival's 61. The comment of the week came from Robin in Utah, who described James as "geeky, cheeky, smoldering, innocent, naughty, funny, heartbreaking. . . but all the while unquestionably sexy!" That just about sums it up, don't you think?

Anyway, if you like your men rugged and outdoorsy, you'll enjoy this week's Face Off, a battle between two toned, tanned hunks who know definitely how to start a campfire.


Mr. Holloway...

Mr. McConaughey...
  • Plays James "Sawyer" Ford in Lost
  • Has starred in TV ads for Davidoff Cool Water and Magnum ice cream (yum!)

  • Recently appeared shirtless on Gay Spy
  • Appears in various rom-coms

  • Has starred in TV ads for Stetson Black cologne and Dolce and Gabbana
  • Recently appeared shirtless on Gay Spy
Which guy would you spend a night under the stars with? Use the space below to cast your vote, giving as many reasons for your choice as you like.

Top Stories

Something Nice to Look At

Something Nice To Look At: Eddie Redmayne
S25 T1.6419820785522 {run_id}