Brandon Routh vs. Tom Welling

Jessica, London on November 11th, 2008
Tom Welling!! xx

Rachel, Florida on November 11th, 2008
Tom Welling. He has the build, the jaw line, the eye color and the smile. As a comic book enthusiast Tom Welling is my first and only pic to play superman.

Casey, California on November 11th, 2008
I have to go with TOM WELLING. He is the BEST Superman now. I think the BEST Superman of all is Christopher Reeves (R.I.P.). No one can compare to him but Tom Welling comes pretty darn close. Even though Tom Welling is 31 he still is "HOT!!!".

Om, Bradford on November 11th, 2008
Tom Welling is gorgeous (especailly those arms hmmm), but I've had the biggest crush on Brandon so I'll choose him.

SuzyQ, Manchester on November 11th, 2008
Tom Welling the best Superman

Johno on November 10th, 2008
BRANDON ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!

Mr T, Suffolk on November 10th, 2008
TOM! Simply beautiful.

Lee, Sussex on November 10th, 2008
To Chris - London: OK then. If we're talking only looks, then its still Brandon rather than Tom! Brandon is gorgeous and seems like a lovely guy. Tom is chunky and seems pretty dull.

Tara, Birmingham on November 10th, 2008
TOM!!!!

Danilo, Anzio (Italy) on November 10th, 2008
Tom welling !!!

Erilyn, Panama on November 10th, 2008
I'll have to pick my precious TOM WELLING!! He is the most cutest guy I've ever met in my life xD I love him so much! And he IS the best superman in the world! TOM!!!

Rick, North Carolina on November 9th, 2008
neither compare to mitch hewer

Kelly, Warrington on November 9th, 2008
tom welling wins by miles no contest

Taryn, California on November 9th, 2008
Brandon Routh did a good job but Tom Welling is my Superman and can sweep me off my feet anytime :)

Sam, Glasgow on November 9th, 2008
Brandon!!!!!!!!

Chris, London on November 9th, 2008
Tom of course. I wouldn't want him with me just so he could act...

Marc, Essex on November 9th, 2008
Tom Welling can sweep me off my feet anytime!!

Lee, Sussex on November 9th, 2008
Brandon. Tom can't act!

Kath, Manchester on November 9th, 2008
It just has to be Tom all the way!!!!! Just hoping that Tom will actually fly in season 8!!! it would lead the way to making the next superman film the best ever they could use the fantastic cast from smallville, clarke chloe, lois, oliver jimmy and of course the best lex ever.... Is it a bird! is it a plane!!! no it's SUPERMAN TOM WELLING..........................

Anuradha on November 9th, 2008
BRANDON ROUTH IS GORGEOUS

HF, south east somewhere on November 9th, 2008
Tom Welling - he's underrated in his role in Smallville, he really brings a lot of charm and warmth to young(ish) Clark Kent.

Mickie, Newcastle on November 9th, 2008
tom all the way baby

Sam, London on November 9th, 2008
TOM WELLING

Dib on November 9th, 2008
tom definitely, though brandon is cute too

It has to be... on November 9th, 2008
Tom! Gorgeous face, hot body too :)

Rich, London on November 9th, 2008
Tom Welling although I would fance Justin Hartley (arrowman?)

Sam, Lancs on November 8th, 2008
tom, tom, tom, tom (well u get the idea)

Dan, Letterkenny on November 8th, 2008
Brandon. simple

Becky, Eastbourne on November 8th, 2008
Although Brandon Routh is the better actor, i would have to say Tom Welling for old times sake. Smallville rocked back in the day but i do think it's about time they brought it to a close. I also concur with Suzy from Manchester, they need to recast Lois in the next film, Kate Bosworth was pants.

Yasmin, London on November 8th, 2008
even though that picture you put of him is ugly and i've never watched smallville...... tom welling

Dan on November 8th, 2008
TOM WELLING IS HOTTTTTTT! PHWOARRRR!

Stating the obvious on November 8th, 2008
It's pretty clear that Brandon's the best Superman - Tom Welling has never played that character.

Superboy, DC on November 8th, 2008
Tom, Tom, Tom. Brandon's digitally altered blue eyes look flat, and we have yet to see Tom don the famous Superman tights. I'm sure that, if it ever happens, I will faint. Watch the season premiere of when Lois meets a naked Clark Kent and you will see that Tom is THE Superman.

Derrick on November 8th, 2008
TOM WELLING IS THE BEST

Jasmine, Manchester on November 8th, 2008
No contest! Tom Welling He's been playing superman for 8 years he's way better than Barandon Routh

Steph, Liverpool on November 8th, 2008
Tom...all the way!

Deborah Lennon on November 8th, 2008
tom welling for definite, he is hunky especially when he has his shirt off! Tom Welling should be the new Superman, Brandon was fine but he is not as good as Tom Welling, as he has played CK in Smallville, its time to put him into those blue tights.

Laura, Surrey on November 8th, 2008
I can't really decide, if i hadn't heard of them before, i'd think they were brothers!!! But... It has got to be Tom Welling.

Anna, Luton on November 8th, 2008
TOM WELLING, by a cleaar mile

Harriet, Nottingham on November 8th, 2008
TOM!!! He may not be the best actor in the world but hes sooo hot! I agree with Ben, the shower scene in season 1 was awesome - they need more topless scenes in smallville these days!