We may be a little too fond of JLS, and we may not get it right (ahem) every single time, but never let it be said that we aren't fair. His One Tree Hill castmates Chad Michael Murray and Robert Buckley have already been given their own Gay Spy galleries, so it's about time that James Lafferty got a crack of the Picture Special whip. Of course, it doesn't hurt that he's not averse the odd shirtless scene, as you'll find out by clicking through all eight photos.