Movies
Che Part 2
Published Monday, Feb 16 2009, 08:00 GMT | By Simon Reynolds | 4 comments

Screenwriters: Peter Buchman, Benjamin A. van der Veen
Starring: Benicio Del Toro, Franka Potente, Lou Diamond Phillips, Demian Bichir, Rodrigo Santoro
Running Time: 127 mins
Certificate: 15
Steven Soderbergh's exhausting telling of Ernesto 'Che' Guevara's rise and fall charts the renowned revolutionary's successful overthrowing of the Batista government in Cuba and his later failed coup in Bolivia. The complete movie runs at a bum-paralysing 257 minutes, so it's no surprise that it's been split into two digestible parts. The endeavour may have been a passion project for Del Toro, but it is Soderbergh who claims ownership of the movie. Perhaps the only A-list Hollywood filmmaker who can legitimately claim to be an auteur, he has director, producer and director of photography credits on Che. At its worst the film risks becoming his epic folly, at its best it's an immersive and unique take on the biopic.
Skipping on several years from Guevara's takeover of Cuba, the action picks up with the doctor-turned-radical arriving in Bolivia incognito hoping to incite another revolution. He still has the fire in his belly but his mind and body have lost their sharpness. Del Toro, almost unrecognisable from Part One with long hair and scraggy beard, plays Guevara as a fading legend. Unsettled by conflict in his own camp, the victim of unwitting sabotage by colleague Tamara (Potente) and stricken with asthma, there's a foreboding certainty that the protagonist won't make it out alive.
With a tad more structure than its predecessor, Che Part 2 is still problematic in that it unfolds at a glacial pace. Though it's at times hypnotic in its lethargy, the episodic structure is not easy to trudge through. Events take place over the course of a year, with Soderbergh exploring a day, cutting to black, then beginning all over again. This stop-start mentality, coupled with the fact that there's little backstory or exploration of what's driving the man whose poster hangs on many a student's bedroom wall, is often frustrating. Soderbergh strives to throw out the established conventions of a biopic and put you right next to Che in battle. He is interested in the man as an icon and not a human being - the film may have benefited from striking a balance between both.
Che's great strength is its authenticity (which it almost loses completely with a bizarre cameo from a bespectacled, Spanish-speaking Matt Damon). Del Toro's performance is a mirror to that in Part One - if that film is Guevara's greatest triumph, then this is his downfall. Towards the end, there's a scene where a captured Che begs a young guard to free him. The guard leaves the room and asks his colleague to take over watching duties, completely deflated that Guevara - the 'celebrity' he has heard so much about - is a complete wreck. Both Del Toro and his young co-star charge that exchange with pathos and emotion.
Che is an uncompromised work from Soderbergh, a filmmaker who manages to retain his experimental sensibility whether he's steering an Ocean's juggernaut or a micro-budgeted indie feature. As one four-hour feature it's too long, and split it still drags and proves enigmatic, but you can't help but admire Che's grounded approach to its remarkable subject.

> What do you think of the movie? Share your views
Your Views
4 Comments
Your Responses
Bruce, Jersey, on February 19th, 2009
I saw this film last week, a long time after i saw the first and although it may fare better when watched back to back, Soderbergh's biopoic was mildly disappointing. I did expect a better characterisation of Che however it was still a highly compelling watch. Have to agree with the previous comment as well, the reviews lately have been of a much higher standard than previous ones (Tropic Thunder 5 stars!!!)
I saw this film last week, a long time after i saw the first and although it may fare better when watched back to back, Soderbergh's biopoic was mildly disappointing. I did expect a better characterisation of Che however it was still a highly compelling watch. Have to agree with the previous comment as well, the reviews lately have been of a much higher standard than previous ones (Tropic Thunder 5 stars!!!)
Ben, on February 16th, 2009
I would just like to say how impressed I am with the standard of reviews as of recent. A lot more insightful and than most of the mainstrean press.
I would just like to say how impressed I am with the standard of reviews as of recent. A lot more insightful and than most of the mainstrean press.
Brett, London, on February 16th, 2009
I watched this as a 2-parter on New Years day and I'm pleased I did it this way instead of dividing it into 2 parts. The second film was definitely weaker than the first, owing to as the reviewer said it's plodding and episodic nature. Together it makes to be a fascinating biopic of a person I knew very little about apart from his iconic image, but separately Part 2 is hard work. Only see this if you have seen part one, as there is no recap and you won't have the character setup from the first film.
I watched this as a 2-parter on New Years day and I'm pleased I did it this way instead of dividing it into 2 parts. The second film was definitely weaker than the first, owing to as the reviewer said it's plodding and episodic nature. Together it makes to be a fascinating biopic of a person I knew very little about apart from his iconic image, but separately Part 2 is hard work. Only see this if you have seen part one, as there is no recap and you won't have the character setup from the first film.
Movie Reviews
'The Vow' reviewChanning Tatum tries to win back Rachel McAdams in romantic drama The Vow.
At the Movies
John Williams's top 10 movie scoresAs John Williams celebrates his 80th birthday, we take a look at his 10 best movie scores.
Movies Interviews
Daniel Radcliffe talks 'Woman in Black'The actor talks to Digital Spy about his first post-Potter outing.
Box Office Charts
'Chronicle' leads UK box officeSuperhero drama Chronicle leads the UK box office ahead of Journey 2.















the best film