Movies
Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen
Published Tuesday, Jun 16 2009, 10:45 BST | By Simon Reynolds | 41 comments

Screenwriters: Ehren Kruger, Roberto Orci, Alex Kurtzman
Starring: Shia LaBeouf, Megan Fox, Josh Duhamel, Tyrese Gibson, John Turturro
Running time: 150 mins
Certificate: 12A
Claiming a hollow victory in this summer's battle of the giant robots, Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen crunches metal louder and more rambunctiously than Terminator Salvation. They're both poor films, but at least Michael Bay's effort is content with being stupid and silly. Unlike McG's Terminator revival, this doesn't flail aimlessly hoping to find profundity in its B-movie idea. For better or worse, Fallen fulfils expectations. It never wants to be a Ken Loach film, it's Michael Bay unwisely off the leash, all explosions, momentum and paper-thin characterisation. The spectacle is impressive, but deep down it has even less of an emotional core than its Amblin-lite predecessor.
This time we're following Sam Witwicky (LaBeouf) as he heads off to college. Leaving behind girlfriend Mikaela (Fox) and his Transformer car Bumblebee, he finds himself zapped by a shard of space rock and his mind imprinted with symbols that lead uber Transformer the Fallen to Earth to wage war against Optimus Prime and the Autobots. Moving from the depths of the ocean to the Pyramids of Egypt, Fallen is a charged up, supersized version of the 2007 box office smash. At times it's a soul-destroying experience, with the bangs so frequent you become desensitised to it all - proof that a high-powered rocket of a film like this can easily become dull and tedious.
Attempts were at least made to ground the last Transformers in something relatable, with Bay wrapping the spectacular action around a nerdy high schooler's coming-of-age and ownership of his first car. Steven Spielberg is credited as executive producer on both Transformers, but his touch isn't evident here as Bay uses his human cast as window dressing (Fox is revealed straddling a motorbike in denim short-shorts!) for jaw-dropping visual effects and noisy robot scraps. Bay, of course, is the filmmaker whose Pearl Harbour showed an attack on an aircraft carrier from a bomb's point of view - it's hardly a shock that he values hardware over humanity.
In Fallen, characters die and come back to life in an effort to lend a sense of drama to the carnage. It's a redundant tactic and robs the film of any tension when the resurrections are so effortless and, in one instance, happen in the space of a couple of minutes. The action sequences, a triumph for CG effects artists, are whittled down to epilepsy-inducing edits, frantic flashes and deafening decibel levels. The sinking of an aircraft carrier, an Optimus Prime vs. Megatron forest smackdown and the finale in Egypt may look cool, but by jettisoning character and story, Transformers 2 feels a bit like watching someone else play a video game for two and a half hours.
John Turturro's government stooge-turned-delhi counter worker provides a flicker of a pulse. He sells the comedic moments with a slightly deranged, off-centre performance and strikes up an entertainingly bickering relationship with newcomer Ramon Rodriguez. The pair's incompetent infiltration of the Smithsonian Air and Space museum to find decrepit Decepticon Jetfire (voiced by Turturro as a grumpy old Brit) is the pair at their funniest. The film is even vaguely topical at times, with President Obama getting namechecked and a brief mention of swine flu. You're left wondering about the fate of Autobot Ironhide, though, whose other guise is a GMC truck. Rebranding himself during financial armageddon is probably not a major concern when there's Megatron and Michael Bay to worry about.

> What do you think of the movie? Share your views
Your Views
41 Comments
Your Responses
Matt, Manchester, on January 7th, 2010
I have not even bothered to witness this diabolic excuse for entertainment, I value my time too highly. To give an example, I once sat and watched paint dry for 15 hours solid. The only scenario where I may watch this travesty, is one in which I develop locked-in syndrome and am wheeled by some unwitting fool into such a position where it is impossible to avoid. At which point I would be praying to all known Gods, past and present to finish me off with a final stroke, or at the very least a mild hemorrhage. Michael Bay is the son of hypocrisy, insipid uninspired mediocrity and is about as appetizing as sawdust. On the day Michael Bay was conceived, the standards of the earth were considerably lowered, to an almost inconceivable level. If Michael Bay was a flavour, it would have tones of thrush cream, a hint of latex condom and a slight undertone of vaginal discharge.
I have not even bothered to witness this diabolic excuse for entertainment, I value my time too highly. To give an example, I once sat and watched paint dry for 15 hours solid. The only scenario where I may watch this travesty, is one in which I develop locked-in syndrome and am wheeled by some unwitting fool into such a position where it is impossible to avoid. At which point I would be praying to all known Gods, past and present to finish me off with a final stroke, or at the very least a mild hemorrhage. Michael Bay is the son of hypocrisy, insipid uninspired mediocrity and is about as appetizing as sawdust. On the day Michael Bay was conceived, the standards of the earth were considerably lowered, to an almost inconceivable level. If Michael Bay was a flavour, it would have tones of thrush cream, a hint of latex condom and a slight undertone of vaginal discharge.
Alan, Newcastle, on January 6th, 2010
This film was both boring and predictable with truly terrible dialogue. Michael Bay seems to be on a one man mission to convert all men of the world into puerile morons. If you liked this film you are on your way to becoming a brain-deal fool who can only respond to either tits or violence, if so you should be castrated as your genes are detrimental to the population at large and it would be best if you carried out this procedure yourself as this is not a cost which should be incurred by good tax payers like myself.
This film was both boring and predictable with truly terrible dialogue. Michael Bay seems to be on a one man mission to convert all men of the world into puerile morons. If you liked this film you are on your way to becoming a brain-deal fool who can only respond to either tits or violence, if so you should be castrated as your genes are detrimental to the population at large and it would be best if you carried out this procedure yourself as this is not a cost which should be incurred by good tax payers like myself.
andrew byrne, ireland, on December 13th, 2009
transformers 2 was great fun. great action and special effects. hats off to michael bay and company. keep up the good work.
transformers 2 was great fun. great action and special effects. hats off to michael bay and company. keep up the good work.
Michael, Gibraltar, on July 13th, 2009
I understand where the reviewer is coming from. The film is not without faults but the action does speak for itself. It is what it is. The numbers the film has made (currently $700) speaks volumes for a steadfast appreciation of a franchise and also people just generally enjoying a good summer romp. There were things it could have done without but I honestly think the good outweights the bad. I also disagree with complaints of it being too long. One can never have enough Robot action!
I understand where the reviewer is coming from. The film is not without faults but the action does speak for itself. It is what it is. The numbers the film has made (currently $700) speaks volumes for a steadfast appreciation of a franchise and also people just generally enjoying a good summer romp. There were things it could have done without but I honestly think the good outweights the bad. I also disagree with complaints of it being too long. One can never have enough Robot action!
Richard, Aberdeen, on July 2nd, 2009
It was like Transformers porn - all the Transformers of, well, Transformers and all the gratuity down to Optimus Prime's sad little face and the repetitive jiggling of Megan Fox's jugs to make it a nasty soft-porn movie. It had the plot, depth and intelligence of Baywatch (not to mention the repetitive running, oh they were running). Blew chunks. Suffered a similar fate as Bay's other franchise, Bad Boys. First - good, sequel - awful.
It was like Transformers porn - all the Transformers of, well, Transformers and all the gratuity down to Optimus Prime's sad little face and the repetitive jiggling of Megan Fox's jugs to make it a nasty soft-porn movie. It had the plot, depth and intelligence of Baywatch (not to mention the repetitive running, oh they were running). Blew chunks. Suffered a similar fate as Bay's other franchise, Bad Boys. First - good, sequel - awful.
Faisal, Birmingham, on July 1st, 2009
This movie rocked, f**k the Journalist!
This movie rocked, f**k the Journalist!
Karen, on July 1st, 2009
Are u freaking kidding me? what the hell is up with 2 stars? and what is that nonsense rant about a storyline? did you wanted to watch "My sister's keeper" and u got your tickets mixed up? WTF! this was the best action movie i have seen this summer so far, i laughed my head off in some parts and it was all i was expecting. Thus, I had a frickin' awesome time and it didn't let me down at all. I think it's pretty obvious you don't like action movies or explosions (which by the way, hellooo! action movies don't need to be also a teary drama...) and you went to the movie closed-minded and already bitching about it. So get a grip, and don't you dare insult Michael Bay, he so rockz! and did a great job. In fact, i suggest you people watch it in IMAX it sooo rulz :)
Are u freaking kidding me? what the hell is up with 2 stars? and what is that nonsense rant about a storyline? did you wanted to watch "My sister's keeper" and u got your tickets mixed up? WTF! this was the best action movie i have seen this summer so far, i laughed my head off in some parts and it was all i was expecting. Thus, I had a frickin' awesome time and it didn't let me down at all. I think it's pretty obvious you don't like action movies or explosions (which by the way, hellooo! action movies don't need to be also a teary drama...) and you went to the movie closed-minded and already bitching about it. So get a grip, and don't you dare insult Michael Bay, he so rockz! and did a great job. In fact, i suggest you people watch it in IMAX it sooo rulz :)
Charl, South Africa, on June 30th, 2009
Uggh! There goes 2.5 hrs of my life! Should have been AT LEAST 40 mins shorter! Shows you just how deceptive a trailer can be...
Uggh! There goes 2.5 hrs of my life! Should have been AT LEAST 40 mins shorter! Shows you just how deceptive a trailer can be...
Paul, NI, on June 30th, 2009
rambles of an old fart if you ask me, get a better journalist for future reviews as 4 the film 5
rambles of an old fart if you ask me, get a better journalist for future reviews as 4 the film 5
Laura, liverpool, on June 30th, 2009
well i actually have not seen it yet. from all the comments i dont think i'll bother!! the first transformers was brilliant. i think i'll wait till its on the movie channels hahaha coz im a stig!!!!!!
well i actually have not seen it yet. from all the comments i dont think i'll bother!! the first transformers was brilliant. i think i'll wait till its on the movie channels hahaha coz im a stig!!!!!!
Richard, London, on June 29th, 2009
In my opinion it is unequivocally the worst motion picture ever made; it was akin to a screen showing 2+2 = 5 for two and a half hours with people hitting you on the head repeatedly with kitchen equipment
In my opinion it is unequivocally the worst motion picture ever made; it was akin to a screen showing 2+2 = 5 for two and a half hours with people hitting you on the head repeatedly with kitchen equipment
Dan, Australia, on June 26th, 2009
You're all douches for saying 2 stars is ridiculous when you're handing out perfect scores! It was choppy, chaotic, and at times, nauseating. It was 'too much' in every way but story development. Did I learn anything new about Sam Witwicky? And Megan Fox is still hot, right? NOTHING CHANGED APART FROM THE CHARRED LANDSCAPE!!! (AND EVEN THAT WAS HARD TO DIFFERENTIATE). No. 2 stars is worthy for this one. 3 for the 1st one (and #1 is one of my favourite flicks by the way).
You're all douches for saying 2 stars is ridiculous when you're handing out perfect scores! It was choppy, chaotic, and at times, nauseating. It was 'too much' in every way but story development. Did I learn anything new about Sam Witwicky? And Megan Fox is still hot, right? NOTHING CHANGED APART FROM THE CHARRED LANDSCAPE!!! (AND EVEN THAT WAS HARD TO DIFFERENTIATE). No. 2 stars is worthy for this one. 3 for the 1st one (and #1 is one of my favourite flicks by the way).
Alex, Cheshire, on June 24th, 2009
too long.... boring/dull..... similar to first film.... wait for dvd.....
too long.... boring/dull..... similar to first film.... wait for dvd.....
Aled, South Wales, on June 23rd, 2009
At 22, I’m in the key demo for this film. After reading all the comment, the same argument people are using is that the film is full of action! A film can have all the action it wants, but unless it has a decent plot to spanning the length of its running time, which this doesn’t (you'd be lucky to find more than an actual hour of plot), it just mindless. A film is a story not just huge action sequences and explosions. Continuous action like that's present here, just gets dull and repetitive.
At 22, I’m in the key demo for this film. After reading all the comment, the same argument people are using is that the film is full of action! A film can have all the action it wants, but unless it has a decent plot to spanning the length of its running time, which this doesn’t (you'd be lucky to find more than an actual hour of plot), it just mindless. A film is a story not just huge action sequences and explosions. Continuous action like that's present here, just gets dull and repetitive.
John, Glasgow, on June 23rd, 2009
I found this movie dull,boring and daft plus its far too sugary also it seemed far far too long like 40 minutes too long. I only pray they dont make a third.
I found this movie dull,boring and daft plus its far too sugary also it seemed far far too long like 40 minutes too long. I only pray they dont make a third.
Lazlo, London, on June 22nd, 2009
This is a movie for 12-15 year old boys. As a 25 year old man, I felt embarrassed sitting in the cinema. It's completely impotent in every way, it was an hour too long, mind numbingly boring, even the action sequences were terrible. 1 star would be generous for a movie this bad.
This is a movie for 12-15 year old boys. As a 25 year old man, I felt embarrassed sitting in the cinema. It's completely impotent in every way, it was an hour too long, mind numbingly boring, even the action sequences were terrible. 1 star would be generous for a movie this bad.
Maria, Leeds, on June 21st, 2009
Personally i thought the movie was amazing! I have read several reviews and all the critics seem to rate the movie poorly and i cant seem to think of a reason why other than you must really really hate the transformers!! And anyway its an action movie the storyline does not need to be great!
Personally i thought the movie was amazing! I have read several reviews and all the critics seem to rate the movie poorly and i cant seem to think of a reason why other than you must really really hate the transformers!! And anyway its an action movie the storyline does not need to be great!
Ben Kuwas, Houghton, on June 21st, 2009
It was ok but really failed to impress! it wasn't an enjoytable, simple anf exciting action film. it was just an action film with no purpose! the idea was good but the filmmakers didn't do a good job putting it on the big screen! the first one was much better!!!!!!!!!!
It was ok but really failed to impress! it wasn't an enjoytable, simple anf exciting action film. it was just an action film with no purpose! the idea was good but the filmmakers didn't do a good job putting it on the big screen! the first one was much better!!!!!!!!!!
Graeme, Sunderland, on June 20th, 2009
2 Stars? Really bad review, sorry, i understand people are entitled to their opinions but maybe you should stick to writing reviews of films or infact watch films that you will enjoy. I truly feel that you went into watching this film close minded and you probably hated the first one, this is coming from a person who loved the first one and really enjoyed the 2nd one because you have to take a movie like transformers for what it is and thats a balls-out action movie which delivers on these expectations. It wont win oscars for best screen-play but that isnt what i want to see from a Transformers film. Please stick to films that you will enjoy i.e. sideways and frost/nixon and leave the reviews of films like these to colleagues who can appreciate them for what they are and give a non-biased reviews.
2 Stars? Really bad review, sorry, i understand people are entitled to their opinions but maybe you should stick to writing reviews of films or infact watch films that you will enjoy. I truly feel that you went into watching this film close minded and you probably hated the first one, this is coming from a person who loved the first one and really enjoyed the 2nd one because you have to take a movie like transformers for what it is and thats a balls-out action movie which delivers on these expectations. It wont win oscars for best screen-play but that isnt what i want to see from a Transformers film. Please stick to films that you will enjoy i.e. sideways and frost/nixon and leave the reviews of films like these to colleagues who can appreciate them for what they are and give a non-biased reviews.
Movie Reviews
'The Vow' reviewChanning Tatum tries to win back Rachel McAdams in romantic drama The Vow.
At the Movies
John Williams's top 10 movie scoresAs John Williams celebrates his 80th birthday, we take a look at his 10 best movie scores.
Movies Interviews
Daniel Radcliffe talks 'Woman in Black'The actor talks to Digital Spy about his first post-Potter outing.
Box Office Charts
'Chronicle' leads UK box officeSuperhero drama Chronicle leads the UK box office ahead of Journey 2.
















I think I saw a film about robots which scared me. I haven't been out since. They did things, things my hoover can't do so I'll take it back to Dixons when they're gone. I sometimes look out of the window when I'm on the train; first class of course. When the doctor told me I was losing my mind I refused to believe him, and I remembered the rhyme; when it rains in Spain the carpet man arrived at exactly ten past six. He was really late and I asked him what time it was because the clocks don't work. They move around the thing and point at things, those fingers, sometimes I think they point at me. They follow me around the room and I can't escape. My grandad used to say you can't escape time and so now I understand. I hide behind the sofa but he still finds me with his big fingers. I call him long finger time man from the future. I think I'm going to sleep now, it's been a long day and my breakfast is cold.