Movies

Valiant

Published Sunday, Mar 27 2005, 00:02 GMT | By Daniel Saney | 5 comments
Valiant
Brought to us by John Williams (Shrek) and director Gary Chapman, Valiant tells the forgettable tale of F Squad, a flight of British carrier pigeons in WWII.

The story begins as Valiant (Ewan McGregor), a diminutive wood pigeon, leaves his tearful mother to fly down to London to enlist in the Royal Home Pigeon Service. Together with Bugsy (Ricky Gervais), brothers Tailfeather (Dan Roberts) and Toughwood (Brian Lonsdale), Valiant must deliver dispatches from the French Resistance to the Allies concerning the D-Day landings.

Despite boasting an impressive array of comic actors (Gervais, Hugh Laurie, John Cleese) providing their vocal talents, the script provides them with little scope to shine. Once the thrill of hearing efficiently though unremarkably-animated pigeons talk like your favourite celebrities, the jokes aimed at the adult audience are generally disappointing.

There are a few good laughs, though they are heavily punctuated by slapstick visual gags as birds fly into window shutters and such, along with playground humour as provided by Gervais’ character’s bodily functions. While this is going on, entertainment can be found looking for supporting cameos from the likes of Rick Mayall and John Hurt.

On the other hand, from a child’s perspective, there’s a lot going on and the dynamic animated action does well to gloss over the fairly unengaging storyline. Children will also be less inclined to grow tired of bird-based puns as quickly as older members of the audience.

Relative to other animated films we have been treated to (Shrek, Shark Tale), Valiant lacks the budget, leaving those expecting the same standard a little underwhelmed by the effects, which makes the importance of humour even more prominent.

In summary, Valiant is definitely one for the kids, though there is just enough material to keep the adults amused for the film’s running time of 75 minutes.

More about these subjects
More: Movies
Your Views
5 Comments
Submit your comments


1 (Awful)   2   3   4   5 (Excellent)

We reserve the right to edit, refuse to post or remove any content submitted to "Your Views". Please read our terms and conditions in full.

Your Responses
3 Stars
1 Stars
Josh, Surrey, on December 29th, 2005
The storyline was weak and anti-climatic. Waste of time.
4 Stars
Jenn, Sheffield, on December 3rd, 2005
Nice film, good to take youngsters to but secretly enjoy. Oh and you spelt Rik Mayall wrong - sorry but I love him.
5 Stars
mary bath, on April 2nd, 2005
Brilliant film. Grossly underrated. Even my 16 year old son managed to laugh! The younger children in the cinema were grabbing on to their parents when the scary birds appeared and then giggling uncontrollably at the abundant jokes and amusing action. Something for all ages. Especially liked Edith Piaf and the French section of the film. Go and see for yourself. It isn't Shrek but that has already been done and it has more plot than Robots.
4 Stars
Claire Bedfordshire, on March 31st, 2005
We took our grandson age 9, and we all enjoyed it. He liked the visual fun, and I liked the old-fashioned "Ealing war film" atmosphere, including the march theme music. Nostagia, I suppose!
2 Stars
gottago, Wirral, on March 28th, 2005
I was very disappointed by this, though to be honest, I really wasn't expecting much of it in the first place! The story can get quite confusing at points. Sometimes I drifted and started thinking about IKEA (don't ask!)... I really don't think the actors put enough effort into their voices. Words that should have been stressed weren't. People who weren't so good at the voices were Gervais (absolutly no expression, just doing his repeating of words like in The Office) and surprisingly Cleese (who was very good in Shrek 2). I know it's hard to do an animation but they could have least put a bit more effort in! Also Dawn French's volume really needed to be turned up! I agree with Dan Saney, many of the jokes were plain old playground jokes. We've seen them that many times that they're not in the slightest bit funny On the plus side, I thought that when the birds were flying they looked quite realistic! Rant over.

Movie Reviews

'The Vow' reviewChanning Tatum tries to win back Rachel McAdams in romantic drama The Vow.
'The Vow' still

Top Stories

BAFTA film nominees with Orange
Watch with Orange Wednesdays and win prizes
Win This Means War luxury screening
A private screening plus hotel stay & dinner for you and 9 friends
Sign up and get two free cinema tickets
LoveFilm 30 Days Free Trial
S25 T1.6178500652313 {run_id}