Movies
Pirates of the Caribbean compcov header

Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest

Published Wednesday, Jul 5 2006, 18:40 BST | By Daniel Saney | 14 comments
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest
Director: Gore Verbinski
Screenwriter: Ted Elliott, Terry Rossio
Starring: Johnny Depp, Keira Knightley, Orlando Bloom, Bill Nighy, Jack Davenport
Running time: 150 mins
Certificate: 12

Captain Jack Sparrow (Depp), Will Turner (Bloom) and feisty lady Elizabeth Swann (Keira Knightley) again form a shaky and unlikely alliance in the sequel to the 2003 hit. Sparrow is having a black spot of bother as he is called up to pay his debt to the infamous Davy Jones. Meanwhile, Will and Elizabeth's wedding is interrupted by their being arrested, leading them on independent journeys in pursuit of Sparrow.

Dead Man's Chest is an extremely busy, fast-moving film, and to get through everything it wants to in 150 minutes, this is hardly a surprise. Packed into the running time is everything you could want from a pirate movie, and unfortunately more. We have a village of cannibalistic tribesmen, the tentacle-faced Davy Jones and the Flying Dutchman, a drawn-out sword-fight on a giant rolling wheel, a kraken, a reunion between Turner and his father. And so on.

It's been widely publicised that this movie was filmed back to back with the third and supposedly final chapter in Verbinski's tale - though even if you didn't know this it wouldn't be too hard to guess just by watching it. It just doesn't feel like a complete story but rather a frantic but bulky part of a larger whole, which means that after two and a half hours the audience isn't provided with what could truly be called an ending or even a particularly interesting cliffhanger.

The main trio of the original's favourites return, though unfortunately we never really get too interested in any one of them, simply because there are so many characters clamouring to be watched. Depp's camp captain is played well, though is too often used as a joke in himself rather than a mouthpiece for them. Bloom's Will is given an interesting subplot in meeting his father Bootstrap Bill (Skarsgard), whilst the admittedly entertaining Keira Knightley is largely redundant plot-wise and just seems to be included for the sake of it.

The plethora of characters, however, are never really the focus of Dead Man's Chest - they all play second fiddle to the special effects, which seem to hold more influence over the plot. Easily the strongest point of the film, the visuals are spectacular. The Flying Dutchman and its crew, humans with fishy mutations, are well-conceived as is the pesky kraken out for Sparrow's blood.

If all we expected was good, often very good, effects and locations, then Dead Man's Chest would surely more than satisfy. It's watchable (if requiring some patience), it's by no means a bad film and will do doubt be lapped up by many. However, after the fresh originality and tighter story which made the first Pirates so popular, audiences will simply be expecting more than this film delivers. Hopefully next summer's instalment will reveal this to be simply a difficult middle act.



Your Views
14 Comments
Submit your comments


1 (Awful)   2   3   4   5 (Excellent)

We reserve the right to edit, refuse to post or remove any content submitted to "Your Views". Please read our terms and conditions in full.

Your Responses
4 Stars
4 Stars
Amy, London, on September 2nd, 2006
I enjoyed it. This was the first time a film has had me scream before, in fact it's the first time I've screamed since the Doctor Who episode 'Impossible Planet'. The plot was slightly confusing though, and where on earth was Keira Knightley? The ending was pleasantly surprising though, and the FX were amazing. A rollercoaster ride of a film, but with a slightly hollow feel. The wheel scene was hilarious though, as was the beach fight scene. Need more soon!
5 Stars
Sammy, Wiltshire, on August 14th, 2006
Cannot WAIT till the next one in the trilogy.
5 Stars
Rebecca, Surrey, on July 29th, 2006
I thought this film was better then ther first, it was a tiny bit too long but overall a brilliant movie. As usual Johnny is fantanstic plays Jack Sparrow really well. Loved this film cant wait for the 3rd
2 Stars
Louise, Hertfordshire, on July 22nd, 2006
I think the above review is spot on. I went to see this this afternoon, and although I enjoyed the film (hey 2.5 hours of Johnny and Orlando is enough for any girl...) I did leave with a bitter taste and feel of dissapointment and "is that it" now we have to wait another year for part 3... I feel they could have cut out about 1 hour and finished up the story really satisfactorily this time. BUT then again Hollywood need to guarantee bums on seats and pounds, dollars and euros rattling in tills for next year I suppose.
5 Stars
Claire, Peterborough , on July 21st, 2006
Saw this last night, fantastic really enjoyed it. Can't wait for the third one now...
5 Stars
Denise, London, on July 19th, 2006
Loved it although it was a bit long. But I really can't wait for the next installment. It does not have to be a masterpiece but entertaining which it was, and I loved all the characters, many we knew from the first film so we did have to go too deep again. It's like The Empire Strikes Back to me that feeling that the last film will really answer all questions and be the icing on the cake.
5 Stars
Dan, Burton, on July 16th, 2006
Ive seen the film and it is amazing! I agree with all the comments below!
4 Stars
Mick, Halesowen (UK), on July 12th, 2006
I agree with many of the comments, "ending" could have had more meaning. Loved the huge hamster-wheel fight though. The audience actually laughed out loud more than I have ever heard in a cinema - got to be a good thing
5 Stars
Holly, East Sussex, on July 11th, 2006
Building on the brilliance of 2003's epic adventure, the unlikely trio of Captain Jack Sparrow (Depp), Will Turner (Bloom) and Elizabeth Swann (Knightley) once again set off on a journey to find the legendary Dead Man's Chest. Although the separation of the characters for most of the film removes many of the comical social interactions seen in The Curse of the Black Pearl, there is never a moment without laughter, especially from the ever-entertaining Captain played admirably as ever by Johnny Depp. The real laughter, however, comes when the characters are reunited towards the end of the film. The special effects are awe-inspiring, from the huge and slimy tentacles of the kraken to the barnacle-encrusted faces of the Flying Dutchman's crew. The beautiful Caribbean scenery is also wonderful to look at. A truly magnificent pirate movie, this film is jam-packed with all the excitement necessary to keep the viewer hooked. The visual effects and the locations are superb; the film contains innumerable laughs and two gripping cliffhangers to ensure the return of all its faithful audience on the release of the (supposedly) final instalment. Here's to a brilliant (and hopefully not last) part next year!
5 Stars
Spongebob, Bikini Bottom, on July 10th, 2006
This was entertainment with a capital E! Look somewhere else if you want emotional depth, blah de blah, it made me laugh and thats what I'm looking for.
5 Stars
Dawn, Middlesbrough, on July 8th, 2006
Excellent film, great special effects well written and truely a pleasure to watch.
5 Stars
Russell, South Wales, on July 8th, 2006
I agree with the other commenters, it was a great film! I even thought the story was good, it was a proper pirate adventure. Yaaarrrr!
4 Stars
Mix_boy, Bardford, on July 6th, 2006
Great action all the way. The story is hard to follow in parts, but overall a great movie.
5 Stars
Ross, Peterborough., on July 6th, 2006
This film was absoloutly brilliant! All the old characters plus loads new ones. Lots of suspense, action, laughter and a brilliant cliff hanger at the end! :D

Movies Interviews

Top Stories

BAFTA film nominees with Orange
Watch with Orange Wednesdays and win prizes
Win This Means War luxury screening
A private screening plus hotel stay & dinner for you and 9 friends
Sign up and get two free cinema tickets
LoveFilm 30 Days Free Trial
S17 T1.8877010345459 {run_id}