Music

Siobhan Donaghy: 'Ghosts'

Released on Monday, Jun 25 2007
Published Friday, Jun 22 2007, 17:44 BST | By Nick Levine | 4 comments
It’s been seven years since Siobhan Donaghy was heard, for the first and last time, on a bona fide hit single. She stole the show on the Sugababes’ Shangri Las-on-WKD smash ‘Overload’, but quit the sulky pop trio a year later after her bandmates apparently invented a new language to prevent her from talking to them. Ouch. Her solo debut – 2003’s Revolution In Me - sold fewer than 10,000 copies, so what hope is there for Donaghy in the frosty pop climate of 2007? The train’s coming and, if she’s not careful, we sure know its destination: the dumper.

All of which makes Ghosts a singularly unlikely triumph. Alongside producer James Sanger (U2, Dido, Keane), Donaghy has crafted a record that manages to be accessible without being crass, ethereal without sounding like the soundtrack to a meeting of white witches on Hampstead Heath, and adult without resembling something that Celine Dion might screech. Recent single ‘So You Say’ underlines Donaghy’s intentions neatly: elegant, understated verses make way for a colossal chorus, while Donaghy’s multi-tracked vocals attack the heartbroken lyrics with real conviction.

Donaghy has admitted that she and Sanger didn’t see eye to eye for much of the recording process – hardly a surprise considering that Sanger was battling heroin addiction at the time – and the tension between producer and popstrel looms large over this record. As Ghosts progresses, Sanger’s soundscapes become ever more layered and portentous, while Donaghy’s vocals become bigger, bolder and more audacious. The results are frequently inspired. The unhinged electronica of ‘Medevac’ houses lyrics about medical evacuation by helicopter – has someone been watching re-runs of Flying Doctors on UK Gold lately? – a chorus the size of Mars and a breathtakingly ballsy vocal from Donaghy. ‘Coming Up For Air’, whose skittish rhythm track recalls Ray Of Light, is as intense and brooding as Colin Firth’s depiction of Mr Darcy. Best of all is ‘Goldfish’, an epic tale of mental anguish whose harmony-drenched final minutes manage to evoke all the sweeping grandeur of ‘Unchained Melody’.

At times Donaghy wears her influences rather too literally – ‘Don’t Give It Up’ could be an offcut from Kate Bush’s Hounds of Love opus, while the backwards studio trickery of ‘Ghosts’ is a straight nick from the Cocteau Twins – but she manages to carve out a winning niche for herself by the end of the record. And how. Nobody else in 2007 is making records this bold, this big-hearted and this defiantly different.



More about these subjects
More: Music, Gay Spy
Your Views
4 Comments
Submit your comments


1 (Awful)   2   3   4   5 (Excellent)

We reserve the right to edit, refuse to post or remove any content submitted to "Your Views". Please read our terms and conditions in full.

Your Responses
5 Stars
5 Stars
Artio, on January 21st, 2011
this album is great. I'm a fan of mainstream music but this underrated album is totally huge melody. My favorite is So You Say and Goldfish! Go Siobhan!!
5 Stars
Jonathan Gardner, on May 7th, 2010
I still listen to this album occasionally! It's INCREDIBLE! Siobhan is criminally underrated and I hope her great music will one day get the attention it deserves! :D - Jonathan | www.YouTube.com/JonathanGardnerTV www.Myspace.com/JonathanLGardner
5 Stars
Mr Zinister, on September 13th, 2009
An album which should have achieved mainstream success, but failed. Perhaps it was too inspired, too different, yet each song is a gemstone. The songs themselves will never become dated, so perhaps there is some hope for the album. But to cling on to such as hope would be futile. It is what it is - a hidden diamond hidden in a sea of coal. A consumer finds such an album by chance. The value of the songs means that they are treasured.
5 Stars
Shaun, on September 26th, 2008
Probably the best album you've never heard. In a more just world, the likes of 'Ghosts' and 'Medevac' would be songs known and enjoyed by all.

Top Stories

Sign up and get two free cinema tickets
LoveFilm 30 Days Free Trial

Charts Roundup

Play online games
Try your luck at Bookworm and dozens more now
S17 T1.5033898353577 {run_id}