Agree with our review? Let us know your thoughts on this single below, and don't forget to include your rating out of five!
Average:

Your responses
Ben, Witney on November 25th, 2009
Saw the video on 4music it's weak. and she's murdered this Foreigner classic!
ella- Nottingham on November 23rd, 2009
a load of crap!
Eddie Isle of Man on November 23rd, 2009
Watched her on X Factor last night and she murdered this song. And that awful screeching at the end! What was all that about? I have never understood why so many people rave about her when she is so hit and miss. More miss at the moment after last nights excruciating performance.
Ami, Manchester on November 23rd, 2009
Horrendous song. She can't sing live, does the worse miming ever and people believe she's still one of the best female singers ever! And nineteen years later, Mariah is still here. Yawn. Time to move over, Mariah! You can't match up to Leona now.
Roxxy on November 23rd, 2009
Re: Live of this song - Actually she can't hit it live. Watch her sing this in the italian X Factor, and it's obvious (if you've already listened to the song) that she's singing with prerecorded lines of the song. FTR: I'm not saying it's bad that she lip syncs. What I'm tryin to point out here is that her whistle when it's live and the high notes are all fake. Though I kinda like the song because it's catchy. But I think she doesn't sound as happy or confident or self assured with this song. There's a bit of blandness in the song. Nevertheless, I'll give it 3 stars for the effort.
Iceman, Leeds on November 23rd, 2009
Please will the almighty one stop this ridiculousness. What has the world done to deserve such monstrosity. I promise I will recycle more and switch off the standby button. Just please don't kill the classics, I beg, I pray and even pledge my eco-warrior ego to you almighty lord. Forgive me for I have sinned but please refrain from punishment such as this!
Jon Millard, UK on November 22nd, 2009
Please don't kill all our classics! It started with Whitney killing I'll always love you (which everybody still thinks is her song) and it just goes on and on, and gets worse and worse, are there no original song
chris, swindon on November 22nd, 2009
wtf mariah can sing anything and make it her own she is great
Alex - Wimbledon on November 21st, 2009
I expected this to be a perfect fit in the same way Without You and I'll Be There were great cover versions by Mariah. Unfortunately this cover is a total let down and is tainted by the same dullness that characterizes most of Mariah's music since the E=MC2 album. She needs a complete style makeover of her vocals, her music production and her image before she will ever get back to Vision of Love or even We Belong Together quality. Sad because she seems like a nice person as well as being a superstar.
LaToya Brixton on November 18th, 2009
EMILYBEMILYB is crazy man.
maryam drammeh on November 13th, 2009
i love you mariah carey
miles pearce basingstoke on November 5th, 2009
This is not about her voice, even though she has covered a song, everyone does. saying that i think its a terrible song, i never like the original and i can see that she is going to become a laughing stock. E=mc2 was good in my opinion, i loved touch my body and i stay in love, bye bye was also good as well. But these 2 singles this one and obessed which only got to no 52 here and 7 in US are awful and not going to do her any favours, lets hope she has got brillant tracks on the album and she has accidently released 2 shitty ones.
Automatic Princess, Leeds on October 30th, 2009
OK. So I think it's a good song, but it's not something you would release as a second single. Mimi honey, you could have done better love! Also, re: Leona, she might have lots of fans and a cool new tune, but unlike Mimi she has to rely on stupid headlines to get chart positions, like "I am so into Twilight" when she has a new single out! Mimi relies on her songs, and doesn't do stupid stories to sell songs. And DS, lol, you give that annoying Hannah Montana thing 5 stars and Mimi 2 stars. WTF!
EMILYBEMILYB on October 30th, 2009
Sorry, I was wrong, after listening again I think it's good. To the person that replied to me sorry I see you write in better English than me. Mariah can count me as a new fan!
Jack on October 27th, 2009
Stunning song with stunning vocals.
jane, uk on October 26th, 2009
an amazing cover
dc on October 25th, 2009
amazing vocals,great cover, brilliant album
Samantha, London on October 24th, 2009
This woman is just ridiculous.
ronaldo,yangon on October 23rd, 2009
This song is the one and only good song on her new album. She needs to do more solo vocals than using those background tracks. We want it clear like she did with ''Hero''.
natalie, london on October 22nd, 2009
love this song, an amazing version
SAm c on October 22nd, 2009
now im nt a die hard mariah fan but i do like some songs off the last album! "Touch My Body" "Bye Bye" "I'll Be Lovin' U Long Time" and "I Stay In Love". But this album sounds complete s**t, a diar lead single in "Obsessed" and a diar cover of the song "I Want To Know What Love Is"! This is awful, its such a dissapointment because u would think she'd be belting out those long notes, it should be a powerful song but this...this...this is a disgrace! shes practicly whispering all through it, its terrible yet it should be a perfect match!
EMILYBEMILYB on October 22nd, 2009
To that person who replied to me...."English" please "english",I couldn't understand a bloody word.And i didn't say you can't like mariah < God talk about wordtwisters.
Nick, Manchester on October 22nd, 2009
Leona Lewis all the way baby! Mariah hasn't got the voice no more. So all that's left is mutton dressed as lamb screeching away to herself in an unforgiving industry. bye bye Mariah. Say hello to the Era of Leona Lewis!
Nick B, Bournemouth on October 22nd, 2009
What I'd like to see is Mariah return to her 'Daydream' era routes, but release original tracks, not covers. For me, she peaked with Fantasy and Always Be My Baby - the urban grind of her recent studio output hasn't rang true, whilst Charmbracelet was insipid and bland. She needs to find that middle ground, and get back to surprising the public... As it is, Mariah couldn't be more in her comfort zone than she is here - More Daydream, less Musicbox please!
cliff, am.samoa on October 22nd, 2009
omg!! you guys are all wrong, this song is a classic and Mariah makes it her own!! ya'll js hattin' cus MiMi is on top of her game :) love ya MC!!
Milissa on October 22nd, 2009
Mariah finds it fine, so lay off the harsh criticism please. It called Memoirs of an IMPERFECT angel for a reason. Nobody's perfect, and she's still giving all that she has. Her real fans will support her regardless. Anyway, her recording is beautifully executed. All she needs to do now is release the video so people can get that oh so important visual.
Jesse on October 21st, 2009
I luv it! its gettin lots of raves all around the world..powerful ballad..lifted way up...Cheers Toast Bravo to you ...MiMi
Megs Sussex on October 21st, 2009
I totally disagree with you, I love this cover and I have it constantly on repeat on youtube.
Gareth, Gloucester on October 21st, 2009
This is a rubbish cover of the song. The backing singers do all the work on this. They should have stuck to the original plan of releasing Obsessed first. Off the back of this I can't see the album doing that well.
tr, OH on October 21st, 2009
Dig_spy begins to claw itself back from the brink of some debatable **** and ***** star awards of late with this brutally honest critique, and you are 2 stars too generous to this (awful) rendition of a rather bad song to begin with.
ASTN on October 21st, 2009
I must be listening to a different song, because what I hear is fantastic, weird...
CAN'T THINK FOR MYSELF on October 21st, 2009
@ EMILYBEMILYB. So, let me understand. Madonna is an Icon for taking sexuality to "another level" and "changing the culture". Can wear bras, show bare breasts in movies and (I heard) was naked in a book. Help me, here. And this was for ALL women. Okay, so I can now flip a birdie to society regarding sex, right??? I'm FREE to think, be, and do what I want, as long as I'm not hurting anyone else. OOOHH, wait now, But, I CANNOT like Mariah Carey or her music. SHE dresses like a slut (''cause she's NOT Madonna). And since she ONCE had a power voice and it's now not so much a power voice any more I should think it sucks. (Never mind that Madonna and many others NEVER had a voice - but I digress) Do I have this right? Just need to know what and how I'M SUPPOSED TO THINK and WHO I'M SUPPOSED TO LIKE. Thanks, so much for your guidance. I should be YOUR lamb. Keep posting, please...I need you.

Kylie's Sparkly Tiarra on October 21st, 2009
She's dreadful - can't sing to save her life, just catterwalls and pretends to hit the high notes. Stale act, stale song.
Graham, Birmingham on October 21st, 2009
Oh dear oh dear oh dear, I don't think I have the words to describe how bad this is. Take one truly awful cheesy song from the 80's and here's the clever bit (!?!?!?). Yes, we add Mariah Carey, undoubtedly the most overrated female singer in the history of popular music and what you end up with is something that is so shockingly awful that it makes me actually feel physically sick. I do also have great concerns for anyone who thinks that Mariah Carey has 'a great voice'. Eh? Her voice is like nails down a chalkboard. Warble warble warble, screech, squeal, howl, warble warble etc....it all sounds like it hurts. Why can't I give this 0 stars?
Gareth juicy lips, Vincennes on October 21st, 2009
Get your nodules removed so you can actually sing again, Mariah. This song, like the current album, is tepid and unsatisfactory because it lacks the power house vocals she built her career on. Fair play that she is trying to make music with what little voice she has left, but it isn't working. Enough is enough, Mariah needs to either retire of get the corrective surgery urgently.

EMILYBEMILYB on October 21st, 2009
Brad...I have actually herd Memoirs and the only good song's on it are Angels Cry & H.A.T.E.U and the rest are crap.And I may have come across as a mariah hater after that post but im actually not!.It just anoys me when all her die hard lambs are in denial saying "She's still got it ect.." When it's obvious to anyone with half a brain and an ear for music that she hasn't.And excuse me... how do i come to every mariah review??.And don't you worry "Brad" i will go listen to my own music that i personally like < Don't you worry about that love!.
James, London on October 21st, 2009
She sounds amazing and really makes the song her own. She's still one of the best singers in the world.
Manish on October 21st, 2009
I love her rendition. She's the Voice!!!
One&Only X on October 21st, 2009
Awful. Just a travesty. What has to happen her. She turned her self into a blonde bimbo with crap songs. Just go away Mariah and settle down with Nick Cannon and have children. Also GROW UP! I won't be surprise if this one flops or might not get released just like Obsessed which was awful aswell.
Brad on October 21st, 2009
Gotta hand it to emilybemilyb she is possibly the most dedicated Mariah hater out there. Probably hasn't listened to the album or song. Knows nothing about Mariah but rumours and gossip. Why do you feel the need to purposely come to every Mariah review and try arguing with people? Get a life and go listen to music you personally like.