Music

Joe McElderry: 'The Climb'

Released on Monday, Dec 14 2009
Published Monday, Dec 14 2009, 07:25 GMT | By Nick Levine | 199 comments
The X Factor champ covering Miley Bloody Cyrus? Huh? Has Sinitta been slipping something into Simon's butterscotch Angel Delight? Actually though, once you get over the initial WTF?!, it becomes clear that 'The Climb' is perfect winner's single material - a shamelessly sentimental power ballad about moving mountains, taking chances, keeping the faith and the like. Crucially, it wasn't too big a hit over here either, peaking just outside the top ten when Cyrus released it back in February.

It also quite suits Joe McElderry, a pop singer who's closer to Cliff than Justin, more kisses 'n' cuddles than damp panties. The South Shields lad is as listenable as ever here, tackling every cliché with his usual note-perfect conviction and comfortably rising above the rumpus on the choir-backed crescendo. The result? As surprising as finding a turkey sarnie parked in front of you five minutes before 'Enders on Christmas night, but just as satisfying in its own stodgy, familiar way. Now, aren't you glad that we – well, 61.3% of us, anyway - plumped for the clearly superior KellyBronze over the bogstandard supermarket jobbie?

Your Views
199 Comments
Submit your comments


1 (Awful)   2   3   4   5 (Excellent)

We reserve the right to edit, refuse to post or remove any content submitted to "Your Views". Please read our terms and conditions in full.

Your Responses
2 Stars
1 Stars
Ross, on December 21st, 2010
I gotta ask Nick why do you always give the winner song a 3?? this deserves a 1 and Alexandra Burke was much more better not a fan of Joe
2 Stars
Moiee,Manchester, on September 23rd, 2010
Oh yeah and your a lesbian ****** ;)
5 Stars
maddy, on September 14th, 2010
cannot wait for joe's new album release in oct his voice is magnifico , go sock it to em joe you deserve to be no 1 .......
anna, on September 6th, 2010
love joe mcederry
5 Stars
G.B, on July 26th, 2010
I love this song and love Joe McElderry. Joe has looks,talent and a great personality. The darling should be proud of himself not ashamed. No matter what the bad people are going to say about him, it comes to no suprise really seems though when you look at him he is a wonderful boy that any nasty bit of work would comment about him. He is gorgeous and awesome. A BIG shame that the single didn't reach # 1 at christmas. Missing him louds and can't wait til hear new hits and that new album coming soon (2010)!
3 Stars
graham wirral, on April 27th, 2010
i like it and think he is a great lad and wish him all the luck..
1 Stars
shawn, London, on February 20th, 2010
Moiee and marina, stop arguing. Whether you like it or not, it's all down to opinion and there is no point trying to shove them down each other. IMHO Joe and The Climb are incompatible. Joe should've covered Stephen Gately's "New Beginning".
Moiee, Manchester, on January 30th, 2010
'I don't recall ever making that comment? Show me and I will gladly say sorry, because yes, if I did say that, it was uncalled for. ;)' I re-iterate: I don't remember making that comment, although I probably did... If I did, then I am sorry. In fact, I could not tell you were foreign... I was mainly griping about text language (which I see a lot of), because for some reason, it really annoys me. I thought you were English... Your English is really quite good. I did not mean to offend you in that way and if I did I apologise. I'm Chinese. ;)
marina, attleborough, on January 29th, 2010
UR PERSONAL ATTACK ON ME IS!!!!! THE FACT THAT I DIDN'T WRITE PROPERLLY! DOES THAT BRING ANY BELLS! I AM NOT BLOODY ENGLISH! I AM PORTUGUESE AND I AM PROUD OF IT! I HAVE BEING WORKING REALLY HARD ALL MY LIFE TO BE ABLE TO SPEAK AND WRITE PROPERLLY SO I THINK I DESERVE A LITLE CREDIT FOR IT, DUNT U! BECAUSE I AM SURE THAT U WOULDN'T BE ABLE TO LEARN MY LANGUAGE THAT QUICK AND BE GOOD AT! ITS ONE OF THE HARDEST LANGUAGES TO LEARN! r u happy now moiee!
Moiee, Manchester, on January 28th, 2010
marina, attleborough on January 12th, 2010: 'moiee u better not say anything wrng abt joe!!! he is more famous that u will ever be. and yes he is commercial u dunt wat the hell u r talking abt u loser!!' I do believe you launched the personal attack first? I don't recall ever making that comment? Show me and I will gladly say sorry, because yes, if I did say that, it was uncalled for. ;)
5 Stars
marina, attleborough, on January 27th, 2010
if i am acting like a litle girl! than u r acting like a old grumpy women! LOL i dunt care if u except my comment or not to me it doesn't make a bloody difference!
5 Stars
marina, attleborough, on January 25th, 2010
U HAVE NO SENSE TO SAY SORRY OR APOLOGISING FOR UR STUPID COMMENT ON THE FACT I DIDN'T WRITE PROPERLLY!!! I AM NOT ENGLISH!!!!!!!!! WAT ELSE DO U WANT TO SAY BAD TO ME!! !! U R GETTING ON MY NERVES!!! I AM NOT A LITLE GIRL U R A F***NG TWAT WISH HAS NONSENSE WRITTING ALL OVER UR FACE!!! NO I DUNT EXPECT U TO ACCEPT ANY OF MY COMMENTS. BUT UR PERSONAL ATTACKS AREN'[T VERY NICE!!! SO WATCH IT!!!
2 Stars
Moiee, Manchester, on January 21st, 2010
Yes, you know what you're talking about. I was merely pointing out that you obviously don't know what I'M talking about. Pfft, if you're not a little girl, don't act like one. Music is your life, blah, blah, yeah, of course. That is still no reason to think your opinion should be valued above anyone else's. You obviously think I should bow down and accept your opinion as the total truth or you wouldn't launch a personal attack. Also, Marina, you do not know me. How can you call me a 'loser', or tell me I will never be as famous as him. Watch your own mouth, Marina, and don't be so hypocritical.
5 Stars
marina, attleborough, on January 19th, 2010
CALLING ME A LITLE GIRL, watch ur mouth, u dunt even know me!!! and yes i know wat i am talking abt because music is my life!!! u better get hold of ur self and wat u say too!!!
2 Stars
Moiee, Manchester, on January 13th, 2010
Marina, that was uncalled for. Yes, I know he is famous at the moment, probably more so than I ever will be. But how famous will he be in a few years? As famous as Steve Brookstein? As famous as Michelle McManus? I wouldn't want that fifteen minutes of fame for winning a TV talent show. Did I criticise his voice? No, I didn't, because I think he is a good vocalist. I do, however, believe he is not very 'now', not very commercial, and will disappear from the pop scene in the near future. I know what I am talking about, but do you? There is no need to start with the petty personal insults here, little girl.
5 Stars
marina, attleborough, on January 12th, 2010
moiee u better not say anything wrng abt joe!!! he is more famous that u will ever be. and yes he is commercial u dunt wat the hell u r talking abt u loser!!
5 Stars
Linda McArity, on January 5th, 2010
I like him.
2 Stars
Moiee, Manchester, on January 4th, 2010
Not denying Joe is a good singer, but seriously, Miley Cyrus? The Climb? MILEY CYRUS? Oh, Jeez. >_> Colour co-ordination on single cover. . . Not good. Black and white, red, yellow and orange? He's not very. . . Commercial, to say the least.
1 Stars
Samantha, In My Sister's Bedroom, on December 31st, 2009
He Shouldn't Of Won It. He Only Won Coz Cheryl Was His Mentor The British Public Have This Obessesion About Her And They Agree With Everything She Says, When She Came Out About Not Liking Danyl Then Everyone Did. Seriously What Kind Of Music Is Joe Gonna Sing. He Is Just Another Leon. Olly Would Of Been Soo Much Better.If He Had Won He Would Of Either Done Jazz Or R'N'B. 1Millions Pounds Down The Drain. This Is Rubbish To.
5 Stars
pam shelton newcastle, on December 30th, 2009
to the person who said joe sings flat,go see the doctor you need a hearing aid fitted

Top Stories

Sign up and get two free cinema tickets
LoveFilm 30 Days Free Trial

Charts Roundup

Play online games
Try your luck at Bookworm and dozens more now
S21 T1.7993381023407 {run_id}