Music
Blog
“ The Sound ”
Our verdict on the new Keane single
Published Monday, Aug 4 2008, 15:22 BST | By Alex Fletcher | 15 comments

Normally, we'd answer this question with a resounding "No!". However, the group's third album is actually promising to be quite an interesting listen. Recorded in LA, Berlin, Paris and London, with a little bit of assistance from electro-pop maestro Stuart Price (Madonna/Gwen Stefani), the guys have promised the record will "ignore the rules of good taste".

What do you think of Keane's comeback track? Did you prefer their old style? Use the space below to have your say.
Your Views
15 Comments
Your Responses
andrew, cardiff, on October 6th, 2008
its better than anything off their last album but not as good as hopes and fears. liking it though, it grows on you after a couple of listens
its better than anything off their last album but not as good as hopes and fears. liking it though, it grows on you after a couple of listens
Ed, Newcastle, on August 6th, 2008
Very good song, but not as deep and meaningful as the old stuff, and really badly mixed / produced. In my opinion the synth sounds, espcially the over-thin squelchy brass sounds, remind me very much of Nick Kershaw, for those old enough to remember him. The bit the reviewer said sounds like Freddy Mercury is in fact closer to something I heard Robbie Williams do a while back, i.e. "white rap" for want of a better description.
Very good song, but not as deep and meaningful as the old stuff, and really badly mixed / produced. In my opinion the synth sounds, espcially the over-thin squelchy brass sounds, remind me very much of Nick Kershaw, for those old enough to remember him. The bit the reviewer said sounds like Freddy Mercury is in fact closer to something I heard Robbie Williams do a while back, i.e. "white rap" for want of a better description.
Dave, Oxfordshire, on August 6th, 2008
Keane does the Killers! Fantastic!
Keane does the Killers! Fantastic!
Mag1K, Bogota, on August 6th, 2008
I'm fan of the band, and to be honest, I was pretty shocked with the first seconds... after a few times of listening to it I can say that I love it... It's great how much they have changed... I think it's some kind of evolution they're going since their first album... I can't wait to get "Perfect Symmetry".
I'm fan of the band, and to be honest, I was pretty shocked with the first seconds... after a few times of listening to it I can say that I love it... It's great how much they have changed... I think it's some kind of evolution they're going since their first album... I can't wait to get "Perfect Symmetry".
c**head, my chair, on August 5th, 2008
amazing song, amazing band. It's a bit different yeah, but it's still an amazing song and if you listen to it on your earphones and hear all the layers it sounds reaaaaaaallllly good.
amazing song, amazing band. It's a bit different yeah, but it's still an amazing song and if you listen to it on your earphones and hear all the layers it sounds reaaaaaaallllly good.
Ian, Fulham, on August 5th, 2008
Two bit two hit wonders are back.
Two bit two hit wonders are back.
Jane A, Sheffield, on August 5th, 2008
Intro reminds me of Human League. Love Tom's vocals are strong & confident (flashback to Talking Heads) and Tim's lyrics are intruiging, as ever. I like it!
Intro reminds me of Human League. Love Tom's vocals are strong & confident (flashback to Talking Heads) and Tim's lyrics are intruiging, as ever. I like it!
Jane, Darlington, on August 5th, 2008
it's god-awful. loved their old stuff.
it's god-awful. loved their old stuff.
Craig, Port Talbot, on August 5th, 2008
I'm not sure about this, big big fan of all their other stuff but was shocked when I heard this - not what I expected at all!
I'm not sure about this, big big fan of all their other stuff but was shocked when I heard this - not what I expected at all!
Mark, London, on August 4th, 2008
Love it! Got a real 70's Bowie thing going on
Love it! Got a real 70's Bowie thing going on
Dave, Yorkshire, on August 4th, 2008
AMAZING! a million miles away from their previous stuff (which i was a fan of) but this is just in a different league! a fantastic and very brave move. Impressive - a sure fire hit!
AMAZING! a million miles away from their previous stuff (which i was a fan of) but this is just in a different league! a fantastic and very brave move. Impressive - a sure fire hit!
Judith, Los Angeles, on August 4th, 2008
Delicious sounds in my eyes!!!!
Delicious sounds in my eyes!!!!
dave london, on August 4th, 2008
ace track, never been fussed about keane before but im really liking this
ace track, never been fussed about keane before but im really liking this
Mark, Wales, on August 4th, 2008
I'm a bit undecided, I'm a big fan of their old stuff but have a feeling I'll really like this after a few more listens.
I'm a bit undecided, I'm a big fan of their old stuff but have a feeling I'll really like this after a few more listens.








This is an AMAZING song !