The Norwalk residents - who share the same names as the 1980s pop duo - got into an altercation last week after a disagreement, reports the Norwalk Reflector.
Roger Oates was jailed after allegedly biting Scott Hall. Oates has since been charged with felony assault, resisting arrest and obstructing official business.
The fight began on Sunday (December 9), when Hall was watching a football game in his garage.
Hall claims that Oates arrived in his driveway with accomplice Ronald Mantz. Oates is said to have been angry at Hall for not testifying in court on his behalf over an underage consumption charge.
Oates allegedly attacked Hall before leaving with Mantz. They were later arrested at Oates's home. Oates resisted arrest and had to be Tasered by officers.
He remains in custody, while Mantz was released on Tuesday on bail.
Watch the aptly-titled 'Maneater' by the original and best Hall & Oates below: