Lindsay was arrested by police in New York City for third degree misdemeanour assault over accusations that she struck a woman at a club.
A source has now disclosed to TMZ that Lindsay attended Justin Bieber's New York concert on Wednesday (November 28) specifically to see The Wanted, but was blocked from meeting up with them backstage.
She later reportedly joined The Wanted's George, Jay McGuiness and Tom Parker at their hotel bar and the foursome then went to a nearby club, where she apparently became angered by another woman speaking to George.
An altercation is said to have ensued with Lindsay reportedly striking the woman, before trying to exit the club. Lindsay was eventually arrested outside the venue.
The insider claimed that George was turned off by the incident and did not leave the club with either Lindsay or the other woman involved in the dispute.
Representatives for Lindsay and The Wanted have not commented on this latest report.
Lindsay was released from police custody hours after her arrest, but has been given a desk ticket for a court date.
Her father Michael Lohan said today that he was not surprised by his daughter's arrest and pointed blame at his ex-wife Dina Lohan for not recognising that Lindsay has been in crisis.
Lindsay is currently facing a potential probation violation for allegedly lying to police about a June car crash. She could face jail time if she is charged for either incident.
Update: TMZ has since claimed that the conversation between George and the other woman was "friendly" and Lindsay "had nothing to be jealous about".