Later, Natalie sees Kyle on the pier and alerts Heath and Brax. Kyle agrees to go back with them, but is still resistant to testifying on Casey's behalf.
Meanwhile, Natalie convinces Sasha to tell Casey that she may be pregnant, but Sasha can't find a good time to have the conversation with all that's happening in Casey's life. She decides that she wants to leave off talking about it until after the court case so she can be there for Casey, but after chatting to Natalie she finally tells Casey the truth. An overwhelmed Casey struggles to digest the news that he could become a father.
Elsewhere, after a movie night, John offers to fix Gina's light, even though Gina wants to call an electrician. Instead of fixing the light, he blows the power. John attempts to fix every problem in the house, but his attempt to be the ultimate handyman fails. However, his misguided actions result in a sweet moment between him and Gina. He's embarrassed by his klutziness and wants to leave, but Gina insists they go to the hospital to make sure John's not hurt.