'X Factor' poll: Should Amelia Lily have gone?
With four contestants doomed to leave, the first live weekend was always going to bring a shock exit. Kelly Rowland's girls were rightly seen as the strongest group - and so it proved on Saturday's show.
Few could argue too much with Louis Walsh saying goodbye to Jonjo Kerr or Gary Barlow letting James Michael go. Tulisa Contostavlos had a tougher decision but probably thought that 2 Shoes were just too unconventional for the public vote.
But what about Rowland's decision? Did Janet Devlin and Sophie Habibis really sing better than Amelia on the night? Vote in our poll and let us know your thoughts in the space below.
This poll has now closed - read the results here