All 11 remaining girls had to strip off for the All For Eve shoot after being given dramatic makeovers by the judging panel.
Itoje's performance in the nude All For Eve challenge was described as "slightly awkward" by the judges, who didn't think that the 20-year-old Londoner could cut it at the highest level.
Guest judge George Lamb told Elle Macpherson: "If that's the best shot of Elle then she's not cutting it."
Grace Woodward criticised: "You look sweet, but it's verging almost into the saccharine."
"She's just a beautiful girl and that's about it," added Julien Macdonald. "It was a tough week, but it's a competition and someone's got to go."
Britain & Ireland's Next Top Model continues on Monday nights at 9pm on Sky Living.
The Next Top Model naked 'All For Eve' photos: