Sunshine, Mario and Ife admitted to being confused over the intention and details of John James's heart-to-heart with Rachael last night.
"I thought she fancied him and he shot her down," said Ife.
Sunshine then shared her interpretation of the incident, saying: "I thought she walked in and said ‘you don’t like me’ as a joke and he asked her to 'come here for a minute’.
"He kept calling her arrogant. I said ‘do you like her?’ and he said, ‘I don’t like arrogant people’".
Mario wondered whether John James may have been attempting to gain control over Rachael with the talk.
"It’s a very good tactic…be mean to her and she’ll come to him," he said.
Ife wondered whether John James may have simply misread a "come-hither" look from Rachael, who last night admitted to fancying the 24-year-old Australian.
All three did agree that whatever the intention behind the chat, it had left Rachael feeling extremely upset.