Shabby managed to compliment and hug Ben during the evening, as per the Tree's request, and was then asked to pick a housemate to share a date with. After choosing Caoimhe, the pair were called to the Diary Room by Big Brother.
They were then asked to move to a secret room, containing a table with wine and a three course meal. A shocked Caoimhe asked: "Did you know about this?" with Shabby responding: "How possibly could I?" Shabby had put on one of Ben's shirts, but insisted that it was because Nathan and Mario were dressing up as girls, rather than dressing smartly for the date in advance.
After the initial confusion, Caoimhe relaxed into the dinner, saying: "This is lovely", despite making fun of the "elevator music" played by Big Brother, prompting Shabby to say: "You ungrateful cow!"
After half an hour, Big Brother told the girls to return to the main house. The pair brought leftovers for the rest of the group, who had been enjoying their own Jerry Springer game.