During a late night chat with Chantelle, Nick and Nadia, the 32-year-old said: "I think it's a shame about this show, because it kind of overshadows Josie's win. Don't you think?"
"Yeah, of course," agreed Chantelle, as Brian added: "I think she could have potentially won. She'd have been in the final three at least."
"Oh, she'd have won," insisted Chantelle. Nick didn't agree with the duo, however. "Unless people thought she didn't want to be here, and wanted to be with John James," he suggested.
"Yes but knowing the public, they'd have stayed loyal," replied Brian, as the series 1 contestant argued that after 14 weeks in the house, viewers might have been sick of the sight of the Bristolian.