TV
Merlin S01E08: 'The Beginning Of The End'
Published Saturday, Nov 8 2008, 20:06 GMT | By Ben Rawson-Jones | 13 comments

The fascinating moral dilemma at the core - whether Merlin should prevent possible future atrocities by allowing Mordred to die - is very reminiscent of a sequence in the 1975 Doctor Who story 'Genesis of the Daleks' in which The Doctor had the chance to wipe out the evil race in their infancy before they'd barely raised a plunger in anger.
This scenario is as dramatically effective here, particularly through Mordred's sorrowful demeanour and the emotive telepathic wail he lets out when his father is executed. The narrative structure is well developed too, with the final exchange of looks between Arthur and the child a hint of things to come.

The darkness of the episode, visually brought out through expressionistic cinematography, is nicely counterbalanced with some crowdpleasing moments. Merlin's covert use of magic has never been funnier, as shown by the self-walking boots and keys jangling behind Arthur's head, both of which should raise a few laughs.
Entertaining and intelligent family viewing with a pleasingly ambiguous touch, this instalment of Merlin shows how fine it can be when it tries.

> What do you think of the episode? Share your views
Your Views
13 Comments
Your Responses
Danny, UK, on November 10th, 2008
Merlin has shaped up to become my favourite TV show of the year.. I think im actually liking it more then Doctor Who! (But only just!) What an excellent episode it was, I was hooked from start to finish but thats the same with every episode.. thats how I realise what a great show it is
Merlin has shaped up to become my favourite TV show of the year.. I think im actually liking it more then Doctor Who! (But only just!) What an excellent episode it was, I was hooked from start to finish but thats the same with every episode.. thats how I realise what a great show it is
Kate L'pool, on November 10th, 2008
I agree I love the dark ominous undertones and the humour with the walking boots and keys was v.funny. I thought Morgana was excellent I agree she's been underused and I also enjoyed the chemistry between her,Merlin and Arthur, I hope they have more of these three and realise what talent they have. The writing seemed loads better too. I've also enjoyed the shift away from the awkward flirting between Merlin and Gwen to storylines with more depth. I hope it continues. The little boy was v.good as well.
I agree I love the dark ominous undertones and the humour with the walking boots and keys was v.funny. I thought Morgana was excellent I agree she's been underused and I also enjoyed the chemistry between her,Merlin and Arthur, I hope they have more of these three and realise what talent they have. The writing seemed loads better too. I've also enjoyed the shift away from the awkward flirting between Merlin and Gwen to storylines with more depth. I hope it continues. The little boy was v.good as well.
Alan K Wicklow, on November 10th, 2008
Katie McGrath is utterly sublime as Morgana and I agree with this reviewer, this is the strongest episode of the season so far. I really hope to see Katie given more screen-time in future episodes as she has been terribly underused in past ones.
Katie McGrath is utterly sublime as Morgana and I agree with this reviewer, this is the strongest episode of the season so far. I really hope to see Katie given more screen-time in future episodes as she has been terribly underused in past ones.
Paul, London, on November 10th, 2008
Merlin is the perfect remedy to miserable Novermber evenings. I have stuck with it since the start despite some weak plots and shaky dialogue simply because the actors make the characters so likeable and it is beautifully filmed. I couldn't agree more that this has been the best episode so far and makes me look forward to those to come. I think Merlin is severly underrated actually. I do hope the standard can be maintained.
Merlin is the perfect remedy to miserable Novermber evenings. I have stuck with it since the start despite some weak plots and shaky dialogue simply because the actors make the characters so likeable and it is beautifully filmed. I couldn't agree more that this has been the best episode so far and makes me look forward to those to come. I think Merlin is severly underrated actually. I do hope the standard can be maintained.
Chris, Devon, on November 9th, 2008
Yes, yes, yes! Once again we are in agreement! I loved everything about this episode - the scenes where Merlin deliberates over the fate of Mordred have finally convinced me that Colin Morgan CAN act, and Merlin has succeeded in not annoying me at all, even if he is still speaking a bit like a 21st century teenager. Katie McGrath and Anthony Head are my favourites in Merlin so far, and this episode only strengthens it really. And like the reviewer says, it's nice to take a backseat from the action and introduce a very new and different plot to the usual formula. Unfortunately my TV skipped around a bit on the dragon's very important bit (it came at last, thank goodness) but I think we all got the gist of it from the trailers. Did I mention that Asa Butterfield was quite good too? Heehee.
Yes, yes, yes! Once again we are in agreement! I loved everything about this episode - the scenes where Merlin deliberates over the fate of Mordred have finally convinced me that Colin Morgan CAN act, and Merlin has succeeded in not annoying me at all, even if he is still speaking a bit like a 21st century teenager. Katie McGrath and Anthony Head are my favourites in Merlin so far, and this episode only strengthens it really. And like the reviewer says, it's nice to take a backseat from the action and introduce a very new and different plot to the usual formula. Unfortunately my TV skipped around a bit on the dragon's very important bit (it came at last, thank goodness) but I think we all got the gist of it from the trailers. Did I mention that Asa Butterfield was quite good too? Heehee.
Alex - Essex, on November 9th, 2008
Another great magical episode.. It was interesting to watch the mystery around the young boy and I have a feeling that it is not the last time we will see him. The best bits of the episode was the boots walking on their own and the keys rattling and following Aurther around the room. I can't wait for the next episode.
Another great magical episode.. It was interesting to watch the mystery around the young boy and I have a feeling that it is not the last time we will see him. The best bits of the episode was the boots walking on their own and the keys rattling and following Aurther around the room. I can't wait for the next episode.
Joe, S Wales, on November 9th, 2008
Got to agree with Gareth and DS' reviews. Katie McGrath is quite nice and looks great too! Best ep of Merlin so far, if it can hold it till the end of the series then maybe it can get a much improved second.
Got to agree with Gareth and DS' reviews. Katie McGrath is quite nice and looks great too! Best ep of Merlin so far, if it can hold it till the end of the series then maybe it can get a much improved second.
mae, Glasgow, on November 9th, 2008
I've enjoyed Merlin from the beginning but this episode was really exceptional family drama. Its mix of humour, drama, magic and character interaction is a delight.
I've enjoyed Merlin from the beginning but this episode was really exceptional family drama. Its mix of humour, drama, magic and character interaction is a delight.
Charlotte, on November 9th, 2008
I don't think these reviews should be written by somebody who is such a big Doctor Who fan. The shows have little in common but comparisons are always being drawn. I don't think it makes for a fair review.
I don't think these reviews should be written by somebody who is such a big Doctor Who fan. The shows have little in common but comparisons are always being drawn. I don't think it makes for a fair review.
Laura, Northants, on November 9th, 2008
merlin really does get better every week! i used to watch this series just cos it was on, but now i find i actually can't miss it - and even when the plot gets shaky, the acting's always fab. the young leads in this show are really stellar; i love the chemistry between merlin and arthur, which succeeds not only in funny scenes (like the key-hidden-behind-head one) but also in more serious ones. they're both incredibly watchable actors. last night's was, indeed, definitely the best episode yet. like they finally realised that the characters are the show's strongest asset, and giving them a moral dilemma or testing their relationships is always going to be more interesting than just making them run about after something. hurray!
merlin really does get better every week! i used to watch this series just cos it was on, but now i find i actually can't miss it - and even when the plot gets shaky, the acting's always fab. the young leads in this show are really stellar; i love the chemistry between merlin and arthur, which succeeds not only in funny scenes (like the key-hidden-behind-head one) but also in more serious ones. they're both incredibly watchable actors. last night's was, indeed, definitely the best episode yet. like they finally realised that the characters are the show's strongest asset, and giving them a moral dilemma or testing their relationships is always going to be more interesting than just making them run about after something. hurray!
Faye, Exeter, on November 9th, 2008
Wow this episode was amazing! Definitely the best episode yet, no doubt about it! Katie McGrath was amazing, she deserves lots of screen time from now on as she's probably the best young actor there!
Wow this episode was amazing! Definitely the best episode yet, no doubt about it! Katie McGrath was amazing, she deserves lots of screen time from now on as she's probably the best young actor there!
Gareth, Gloucester, on November 8th, 2008
This has to be the best Merlin episode to date! The child was amazing, better than many professional people much older than him. I agree about Katie McGrath's acting, and she's quite good looking too ;) Plus the pre-title sequence contained excitement, unlike the previous few episodes.
This has to be the best Merlin episode to date! The child was amazing, better than many professional people much older than him. I agree about Katie McGrath's acting, and she's quite good looking too ;) Plus the pre-title sequence contained excitement, unlike the previous few episodes.
Tube Talk
'Simpsons' ultimate countdown (10-6)What is the ultimate Simpsons episode? Our countdown continues.
TV Interviews
'Upstairs Downstairs' Neil Jackson Q&ANeil Jackson chats to Digital Spy about Upstairs Downstairs series two.
Reality Bites
'Big Fat Gypsy Weddings' returns: ReviewReality Bites's verdict on the return of Big Fat Gypsy Weddings.
TV Ratings
Latest 'TOWIE' grabs nearly 950k on ITV2ITV1 edges BBC One last night thanks to coverage of Champions League football.















Thank the Lord! Both the plot and the acting were spot on this week, making it v. enjoyable to watch. Each & every one shines in their screen time, showing the moral dilemma as the line between right and wrong, good and evil is blurred. Can't WAIT for the next episode!