US TV
'Heroes' S03E12: 'Our Father'
Published Wednesday, Dec 10 2008, 22:46 GMT | By Ben Rawson-Jones | 13 comments

The time hopping worked well, as both Claire and Hiro shared emotive, tender meetings with their parents. The latter, mistaken for a chef, features in one particularly poignant scene where he hears his own father slating him while standing alongside his junior self! Besides, it’s a real pleasure to see George Takei ruling the roost as Kaito – as opposed to picking cockroaches out of Joe Swash’s orifices in the Australian jungle.
Sylar provides a great deal of the excitement and thrills throughout the episode. He’s recently undergone something of an emotional crisis, but his return to full-on villainy is superb and features plenty of enjoyably corny quips. In a way, Sylar is like an old rock band who decide to ditch their new material in favour of playing their greatest hits.
Sylar’s suggestion of “cake?” is a real gem when a group of office workers storm into a room trying to throw a surprise birthday bash for Sue Landers – only to see her in a less than celebratory condition. On a more serious level, his bullet-stopping confrontation with Arthur Petrelli, complete with a life-changing Q&A session, is one of the standout scenes in this inconsistent third season of the show.
Moreover, while it’s sad to lose Elle and Arthur Petrelli - both of them seem pretty dead and look likely to stay dead - given the recent revival gimmicks on the show, it’s nice to think that it’s moving in the right direction on this front. Or else there’s hardly any suspense or drama when it comes to the fates of the characters.

> What do you think of the episode? Share your views
Your Views
13 Comments
Your Responses
Andrew, London, on December 12th, 2008
This was one of the best episodes of a very inconsistent series so far. Hiro meeting his mother and also Clare and her adoptive parents. It's something I've wondered about in my own life so it was interesting. Also Sylars return to villainy is long overdue, I don't know why they messed around with that. He's a bad guy. It's ok if they make it possible to work with him on occasion or that he isn't completely merciless but he's bad so let him carry on with that. Good to hear about original writers coming back because all of this power swapping is very annoying.
This was one of the best episodes of a very inconsistent series so far. Hiro meeting his mother and also Clare and her adoptive parents. It's something I've wondered about in my own life so it was interesting. Also Sylars return to villainy is long overdue, I don't know why they messed around with that. He's a bad guy. It's ok if they make it possible to work with him on occasion or that he isn't completely merciless but he's bad so let him carry on with that. Good to hear about original writers coming back because all of this power swapping is very annoying.
Paul Carlisle, on December 12th, 2008
Finally a little emotion. With all the plot the writers missed out character moments. Masi once again proves that he's a REALLY good actor. Upset that Elle is definatly dead even though she clearly died las episdode.
Finally a little emotion. With all the plot the writers missed out character moments. Masi once again proves that he's a REALLY good actor. Upset that Elle is definatly dead even though she clearly died las episdode.
Rachel, on December 12th, 2008
Loved this episode! Sylar's return to villiany is fantastic, he's so much better at being the bad guy! (Oh, and Bob from Massachusetts - A shot to the head would kill someone with Claire's ability, it mentioned that in a previous episode with Adam Monroe.)
Loved this episode! Sylar's return to villiany is fantastic, he's so much better at being the bad guy! (Oh, and Bob from Massachusetts - A shot to the head would kill someone with Claire's ability, it mentioned that in a previous episode with Adam Monroe.)
Ash, Kent, on December 11th, 2008
I figured Arthur knew to appear there and then from making a "future drawing". I loved Sylar in this episode "This won't hurt *woman uses her power* you got me, I lied". Sylar is like Dexter, deliciously dark with his one liners. It is kind of a shame for him though that he won't become "Gabriel" again like we saw in episode 4. Him trying to find a new path as hero/anti-hero/loving son etc was one of my favourite things about Volume 3. Finally, YAY for George Takei appearing!
I figured Arthur knew to appear there and then from making a "future drawing". I loved Sylar in this episode "This won't hurt *woman uses her power* you got me, I lied". Sylar is like Dexter, deliciously dark with his one liners. It is kind of a shame for him though that he won't become "Gabriel" again like we saw in episode 4. Him trying to find a new path as hero/anti-hero/loving son etc was one of my favourite things about Volume 3. Finally, YAY for George Takei appearing!
Chi Poulton, on December 11th, 2008
Definately Best episode up to date in the season. Anticipating the forthcoming events !
Definately Best episode up to date in the season. Anticipating the forthcoming events !
L, Glasgow, on December 11th, 2008
Best episode of Season 3 yet! Very touching scene with Hiro, and it's great to see Sylar back to true villianous form. Cake, anyone?
Best episode of Season 3 yet! Very touching scene with Hiro, and it's great to see Sylar back to true villianous form. Cake, anyone?
Yasmina,London, on December 11th, 2008
Yep,a fabulous episode. The scene with Hiro and his mum was heartbreaking. And Sylar!! OMG. HE'S BAACK!!
Yep,a fabulous episode. The scene with Hiro and his mum was heartbreaking. And Sylar!! OMG. HE'S BAACK!!
brunoss,stoke, on December 11th, 2008
even though i enjoyed the eclipse episodes this one was really good though abit of nice elle eye candy has gone!! we need another fit gal aswell as hayden in there lol!! what will happen between the petrelli brothers is going to be exciting could pete kill nathan for carryinn on arthurs work shall have see next week!!!+ i think we will see more of arthur through past times of heroes woo and to paul from durham i think arthur probably saw this has he now pants the future and time travels through peters powers
even though i enjoyed the eclipse episodes this one was really good though abit of nice elle eye candy has gone!! we need another fit gal aswell as hayden in there lol!! what will happen between the petrelli brothers is going to be exciting could pete kill nathan for carryinn on arthurs work shall have see next week!!!+ i think we will see more of arthur through past times of heroes woo and to paul from durham i think arthur probably saw this has he now pants the future and time travels through peters powers
Paul, Durham, on December 11th, 2008
Much better than last week; George Takei was excellent - as was Masi Oka in very emotional scenes. How did Arthur Petrelli know to appear when he did though?
Much better than last week; George Takei was excellent - as was Masi Oka in very emotional scenes. How did Arthur Petrelli know to appear when he did though?
Bob, Massachusetts, on December 11th, 2008
The Petrelli death made no sense. The Haitian blunts all powers. Sylar and Petrelli, if the Haitian was weakened then both Sylar and Petrelli should have had powers. Plus when old man Petrelli stole Peter's powers he also had Claire's powers. Therefore this episode makes no sense unless they mean to bring old man Petrelli back. Otherwise nice to have crazy Sylar back. I am tired of Hiro playing the fool.
The Petrelli death made no sense. The Haitian blunts all powers. Sylar and Petrelli, if the Haitian was weakened then both Sylar and Petrelli should have had powers. Plus when old man Petrelli stole Peter's powers he also had Claire's powers. Therefore this episode makes no sense unless they mean to bring old man Petrelli back. Otherwise nice to have crazy Sylar back. I am tired of Hiro playing the fool.
Frankie, Toronto, Canada, on December 10th, 2008
One of the best episodes so far this season me thinks.
One of the best episodes so far this season me thinks.
ed, kent, on December 10th, 2008
The episode I've been waiting for - much, much better - after stealing Hiro's powers - Arthur had to die this time. Good to see Gorjus George back in it.
The episode I've been waiting for - much, much better - after stealing Hiro's powers - Arthur had to die this time. Good to see Gorjus George back in it.
Tube Talk
'Freaks and Geeks': Tube Talk GoldTube Talk Gold heads back to the '80s and remembers Freaks and Geeks.
2012-13 Season
John Stamos to star in 'Little Brother'The former Full House actor will star in the comedy pilot Little Brother.
US TV Interviews
'Celebrity Apprentice' Donald Trump Q&ADonald Trump teases the new season of Celebrity Apprentice.
US TV Ratings
'Vampire Diaries' soars to 3m for The CWThe Vampire Diaries and The Secret Circle perform well for The CW.















A great episode, it's about time Arthur Petrelli died, he was getting annoying. Such a shame about Elle, such a brilliant character. Why kill her? She will be sorely missed.