'Lost': Season Four Review

Published Sunday, Jun 8 2008, 10:29 BST | By Ben Rawson-Jones | 17 comments
'Lost': Season Four Review
In the latter half of its fourth year, Lost hit its stride in spectacular fashion, recalling the outrageously addictive nature of its debut season. Here's our grand overview of the year, covering the good, the bad and the Hurley. Unlike a Dharma Initiative videotape, we'll see it through to the bitter end. Don't forget to leave your comments on Lost's fourth season below.

There's no doubt that the show benefited from the largely masterful use of flashforwards, giving us tantalising glimpses into the future and sending our imaginations into a frenzy as we scrambled to figure out the missing pieces in the grand puzzle. Just who are the Oceanic Six, why has Hurley gone mad, and what led the polar bear to the desert?

Fortunately, Lost avoided a serious case of X-Filesitis by actually answering all these questions and avoiding terminal frustration for the audience. Undoubtedly, the vastly increased focus has stemmed from the fact that the seasons are now two-thirds of their usual length and an end date for the show has been announced. Early fourth season episodes took their time to find the right balance and occasionally suggested that there was more life left in Naomi's corpse, but everything clicked into place wonderfully in the end.

The emergence of Charles Widmore's Kahana freighter ensured that Lost provides as much thrills in the present as it does when peeking at the past or future. The vicious Keamy and his faceless mercenaries scythed their way through the jungle, with the execution of Alex in front of her stunned father Ben Linus providing a real shock - and vitally adding to the increasing ambiguity surrounding Linus. Could he be the good guy after all?

The freighter also introduced the less bloodthirsty likes of Charlotte, Daniel and Miles to island life. Their secret, non-benevolent mission was gradually unravelled, plus flashbacks to Daniel's time-travelling experiments with his pet rat Eloise and Desmond heightened the science fiction element of the show. It's interesting to note that Eloise was given a far better send off than Danielle Rousseau, as her demise was distinctly underwhelming and unsatisfying.

It also brought the wonderful figure of Frank Lapidus onto the shores, a real cult figure. Michael Dawson was also lurking on board as Ben's mole and thankfully his enthralling backstory was the main focus of an entire episode that further explored the mystical properties of the island, for Michael couldn't kill himself if he tried. Alas, the island - in the form of dead man walking Christian Shephard - allowed him to sail off to the afterlife in the end, tragically without a reunion with son Walt.

Still, at least we were given the saccharine-laced smoochfest between Des and Penny in the end. Given what we know from the flashforwards, can Des prevent Ben from killing off Widmore's daughter as revenge for the slaying of Alex? Let's hope Alan Dale returns to reprise his role as Charles in the future and takes a break from his apparent quest to appear in every cult television show known to mankind. The scope of the uber-villain's dealings is immense - just witness the stunning images beamed back from the crash wreckage of the fake Oceanic Flight 815.

The mystery of how Claire's baby Aaron came to be Kate's son was explained over the latter half of the season. In scenes reminiscent of the black lodge from Twin Peaks, Claire snuck off with her father into Jacob's hut and abandoned her baby. The cover story of the Oceanic Six caused Kate to claim Aaron and saw an increasingly derailed Jack hooking up with Sawyer's former squeeze - a breath of fresh air following the somewhat tedious and red herring nature of his flirtations and snog with Juliet on the island.

Ultimately, none of them were at it like rabbits at all, unless Bernard and Rose got jiggy on the sly. For we now know what happens to rabbits on the island - they get stuffed into a time-travelling device by a sinister Oriental chap lurking in the underground Orchid station.

Other plus points worth mentioning include the magnificent comradeship between Locke and Linus, the impressive acting by Matthew Fox as troubled Future Jack, the return of the Black Smoke Monster, Hurley's chess match with Mr. Eko and above all - Michael Emerson adding so many contrasting layers of humanity and callousness to the character of Benjamin Linus.

Also, one particular scene stands out in the series. This occurred when Claire's mother turned up at Christian's funeral to spill a few beans to Jack, who stuck to his cover story and claimed to have never met his newly discovered half-sister. The look on Jack's face was harrowing to behold, especially when Claire's mother looked at the baby in Kate's arms - not knowing that Aaron is her own grandson! This moment could have been melodramatic and overblown, but instead was wisely understated.

Lost's fourth season was superb, as an intricate puzzle starts to slot together merging past, present and future. All eyes are now on next year, with the finale's revelation that Locke was the man in the coffin prompting plenty of speculation. Fingers crossed that we discover just what Sawyer whispered to Kate before leaping out of the helicopter and how much of a bill Richard Alpert has racked up with his Botox treatments. We can't wait.

> What do you think of Lost's fourth season? Share your views
Your Views
17 Comments
Submit your comments


We reserve the right to edit, refuse to post or remove any content submitted to "Your Views". Please read our terms and conditions in full.

Your Responses
sylvain, québec., on December 30th, 2008
I've just finished watching the 4th season of LOST, my xmas gift, and my wife asked me why does Locke have papers on his coffin with the name Jeremy Bentham written on it? my answer: Locke somehow got off the island and i'm sure season five will tell us how and because he is dead to the rest of the world, he had to use another name to get back on the continent and find the Oceanic 6. My guess is season 5 will take us on a wild ride with flashforwards and flashbacks. We will find out how Ben got to october 24th 2005 in Tunisia when he moved the island in december 2004 or was it then? Loved season 4 like the rest.
Ewen, Scotland, on December 27th, 2008
i agree, the only down point to this fantastic season of lost was michaels storyline and the his death. i felt he had more to give in regards to his story with walt ;) xx
Joseph, Canada, on December 13th, 2008
Everything was excellent, especially the development of Ben. However, the only aspect that was lacking was the Michael story line. IT left much to be desired
Rob , canada, on December 10th, 2008
This season was a bit short and started slow, but by the end, i was hooked remember THE CONSTANT?!?! sickest episode ever!
Ryan J Brown. Lincholn., on June 26th, 2008
I don't need to say anything other than OUTSTANDING!
Tash, Cornwall, on June 11th, 2008
As much as I love Lost...I hate that this series was soooo short! Wheres the rest? Its also getting even stranger, with more jumps back and forth and still more questions left unanswered. I still want to know what the smoke monster is!
gemma rogers, london, on June 9th, 2008
i thought that season 4 was by far the best out of all the seasons. The writers got their act together and really made it believable and definatley leaving with the need to watch more. im very intrigued to know what happens next...
Ben, Leicester, on June 9th, 2008
Season 1 - 5 stars 2 - 2 stars 3 - 2 stars 4 - 4 stars
Barry, Fife, on June 8th, 2008
Lost, Battlestar Galactica, 24, Sopranos... take any two hours of any of these progrmmes and compare it to anything you can see at the cinema today. TV finally killed the cinema - with quality content - who would have believed it! Lost season 4 was without doubt the most exilerarting, suspense filled and original few hours of televsion I have ever seen. Gone is the slow moving, repetative feeling of season 2 (and some of 3) and in it's place a frantic story in three different timezones masterfully linked together - with a lot more to come. Season 4 definately scored by being shortened by the writer's strike, it jst feels a much faster moving show in a fewer episodic format - although I'm already feeling withdrawal symptoms knowing I've now gotta wait unil next year. Is it possible for this show to get any better??
Daniel, Nottingham, on June 8th, 2008
Season 4 has been... Wow. It feels like a different show to Lost season 1-3 coz of the new set up but i wish we had, had an end from beginning because that would have Lost even better! I no a lot of people have been complaining about Danielle but she actually did not like living in Hawaii and asked for her character to be taken out so that was not really the creative peoples fault. Anyway the fact that were starting the 5th season and we dont hav a clue were the show is going to go (mostly to do with the island) is outstanding. Lost is a one of a kind show!
Andrew, on June 8th, 2008
First things first I've been the biggest Lost fan for ages. Therefore it is a surprise to myself to say that I didn't enjoy this season nearly as much as the first 3. It's difficult to put my finger on, maybe its the gradual descent of mystery from seasons 1-3 to season 4 which was a lot more Sci-fi and miliatary based which I didn't enjoy much but the cutdown in episodes made the whole thing pass very quickly without very much happening. Also the deaths of Michael,Alex and Danielle bothered me. I know Lost is famous for its death scenes but since the gradual demise of nearly all my favouraite characters in Seasons 1-3 were bearable.It was Danielles that shocked me most, 3 seasons of her being mysterious and unexplained to be offed so quickly and buried before we knew it. As for Michael-his actor is right, what a waste. Sorry for moaning but im still gonna watch :P
Alex, Cheshire, on June 8th, 2008
Great review, sums up everything really. Absolutely fantastic season and by far my favourite. I personally loved season 3 but thats has exceeded expectations and delivered a truly spectacular show that makes the likes of prison break season 3 and heroes season 2 look pathetic. Every aspect was brilliant and i still can't decide which out of the the constant and the finale is the best piece of television ive ever witnessed. Well done to everyone involved and please oh god please keep it up next year!
Jacob, London, on June 8th, 2008
Although I think every Season of LOST is simply amazing, I have to say that the pace of Season 4 made it stand out as one of the most gripping, excitable Season’s of a television show I have ever experienced; each episode was pakced with a classic moment, that will go down in history as the biggest cliffhangers ever: . Sayid working for Ben . Kate having Aaron in the future . Jin being dead in the future? . Ben and Widmore’s confrontation . ‘We have to move the Island’ . Locke in the coffin And, together with that, the flashforwards and Island/Freighter quests featured within the episodes featured a much more revaltory/darker story-telling angle than LOST usually does. In the Season’s stand-out episode, ‘The Shape of Things to Come’, as Keamy counts down from ten until he puts a bullet in Alex’s head – you just expect Ben to come up with a plan to prevent this from happening, at the last second… However, it does not come, and Keamy gets to zero, and mercilessly executes her, without thinking twice. Cue Ben summoning Smokey – a great mystery which has revelations revealed each appearance it makes. Never before have I seen a programme introduce so many new characters who have been well-perceived; Daniel Faraday, Miles Straume, Frank Lapidus, Matthew Abbadon, to name but a few. Eat your hearts out Nikki and Paulo (who still had one of Season 3’s biggest underrated episodes, ‘Exposé’)… After four Season’s, LOST remains my favourite programme – a feat well earned; each Season seems to surpass the previous one, and the transition from mystery-driven episodes to character-driven episodes makes it unpredictable as to what you’ll be watching each week; Season 4 was the year of Yunjin Kim (Sun Hwa-Kwon) performing an Emmy-deserving role.
Mike, Manchester, on June 8th, 2008
I completely agree with the review, season 4 was excellent and finally some questions are being answered (although there are still more being asked!!). It's good that there's an end in sight as (hopefully) it means that other loose ends will start to be tied up. As for what Sawyer whispers to Kate, it's been mooted that he says "I have a daughter in Alabama, you need to find her, tell her i'm sorry......" Roll on season 5!!!
katie, london, on June 8th, 2008
This was the best season so far for me personally. LOST is incredibly good !!!!!!!
Dan, Walsall, on June 8th, 2008
I completely agree with your review; season four I feel has been the best and I know that it can only get better in the next two seasons. I was particualy impressed by the new characters this season; it was a lot better than the introduction of Nikki and Paulo! The only thing I didn't like about this season was in "The Shape of Things to Come", yes a superb episode, but the scene where all those 'redshirts' were killed and Sawyer dodging the bullets was simply poor - also I didn't like the death of Danielle!
Bob, Glasgow, on June 8th, 2008
A. Mazing. I've stuck with this fantastic series since the beginning, and it's paying off BIG style. The writers now need to keep this momentum going, and not make season 5 another season 2 -which although in my opinion was good, was nowhere near the standard they have now reached.

Top Stories

Play online games
Try your luck at Bookworm and dozens more now
DS Competitions
Win £3,000 of vouchers from Thomson or First Choice.
S28 T2.6624219417572 {run_id}