Christina thinks it was the "prettiest and most moving" performance of the day ,and that it was really consistent. Cee Lo says it's a beautiful song, they performed it in an "enchanted" way and he likes both singers equally. Now it's Adam's turn to decide...
Mary J Blige's has got some notes for both girls, but she is "completely shocked" by Melanie's vocals. Caitlin is a little scared - she's got a bit more of a Florence Welch voice, but hopefully they can make it their own.
Blake thinks Aquile is amazing but wants to talk more about Natalie - she's already "so good" despite her lack of experience, he says. However, it's Christina's decision, and she decides to keep Aquile.
Natalie suffers a bit with a lack of confidence, though Billie Joe Armstrong tells her that she sounds a bit like Natalie Merchant. Aquile, who already knows the track, goes nuts with it. They've really got to work on having more chemistry though, because it's pretty awkward at first.
Cee Lo is upset that they concentrated more on the choreography than stretching themselves as artists in the song. Because of that, it boils down to a personal preference and he decides to keep Cody.