The former Family Matters star, who was recently forced to deny allegations that he was abusive towards his ex-girlfriend, only managed to collect 1.5% of reader votes for his Week 4 Tango with partner Kym Johnson.
Not faring much better were Gladys Knight and Sherri Shepherd, whose performances appealed to just 2.6% and 2.9% of users respectively, while Roshon Fegan and William Levy may yet find themselves in trouble, polling a precarious 3.6% each.
Gavin DeGraw, who landed in last week's bottom two, will hope to avoid a repeat result after attracting a solid 5.1% of votes, while Melissa Gilbert, who suffered "mild concussion and whiplash" during Monday's episode, looks to have done enough to be safe, winning over 6.9% of readers.
Although this week's judges' favourite Donald Driver polled an impressive 20.4%, it wasn't enough to overhaul Katherine Jenkins, who comfortably finished top of our poll yet again with 43.8%.
Find out who gets sent home in Dancing with the Stars tonight at 9/8c on ABC.
Watch Katherine Jenkins and Mark Ballas perform the Paso Doble on Monday night's show below: